NATIONAL INTEGRATED DEVELOPMENT STRATEGY
Health Sector
| Table
of Contents |
|
Chapter 1 |
Introduction |
| Chapter 2 |
Economic and Social Influences on the Health Sector |
| Chapter 3 |
Trends in the Health Situation |
| Chapter 4 |
Policy, Organizational and Legal Challenges |
| Chapter 5 |
The Provision and Utilization of Health Services |
| Chapter 6 |
Resources |
| Chapter 7 |
Recommendations and Conclusion |
|
References |
|
List of Tables |
| Table 1 |
Population by Age Group in 1980 and 1991 and
Projections For the Years 1996 and 2011 |
| Table 2 |
Demographic Indicators 1980, 1991, 1995 and 1996 |
| Table 3 |
Principal Causes of Mortality in 1991 to 1995 |
| Table 4 |
Principal Causes of Morbidity (Hospitalization) in
1996 |
| Table 5 |
Accidents and Trauma 1991 to 1995 |
|
List of Appendices |
| Appendix 1 |
Economic Data in the BVI 1991 to 1996 |
| Appendix 2 |
Demographic Information, BVI, 1992 - 1995 |
| Appendix 3 |
Ministry of Health Organizational Chart 1997 |
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
Health is a dynamic state that is individually
perceived. Understanding health and illness requires a careful study of
both individuals and the entire population. Factors such as culture,
education, economics, geographic location and healthcare availability all
impact on the health of individuals, families and communities.
There is a great diversity of definitions and opinions
about the meaning of health and illness. However there seems to be
agreement that both terms represent interactive states between social,
physical, psychological and/or environmental factors. Within this frame,
there are several important points to discuss. Perhaps the most critical
one is that health is not only the absence of disease, but encompasses all
of man's well-being including social, psychological and spiritual
dimensions as well as environmental, economic, educational and
recreational factors. Health, as defined by the World Health Organization
(1960), is the state of complete physical, mental and social well being
and not merely the absence of disease or infirmity.
The health sector strategies essentially aim to achieve
the following:
- Equity and Access: providing greater opportunities for access to a
minimum level of health care on the basis of need for care and not
solely on ability to pay.
- Effectiveness and Quality: establishing the basis for a well
integrated health care system offering quality services at primary,
secondary and tertiary levels.
- Efficiency: maximizing the use of resources and minimizing the cost
through strategic planning and sound management.
- Financial Sustainability: establishing procedures to reduce the
expenditure gap between increasing costs and limited resources, and to
ensure ongoing feasibility of the system.
- Inter-sectoral Collaboration and Community Participation: fostering
cooperation between the Ministry of Health and other public agencies
and the private sector and involving communities in monitoring and
implementing the reform.
The first four objectives outlined above form core
elements of a reform strategy; the fifth is considered to be a critical
supporting objective given the legacy of a highly compartmentalized and
hierarchical public health system.
Historical Background
The Ministry was established in 1979 as a fourth
Ministry taking part of its portfolio from the Chief Minister’s Office
and part from what was formally the Ministry of Natural Resources,
Immigration and Public Health. It was originally named the Ministry of
Social Services which is representative of the subjects for which it is
responsible. In 1983, the name was changed to the present Ministry of
Health, Education and Welfare.
The Ministry has a wide range of distinctly different
specialist responsibilities that extend across a broad spectrum, from
Caribbean Studies to Prison Management. The services provided by the
Ministry are particularly sensitive and attract considerable public
attention as they impact on the social, educational and health needs of
the territory.
The overall goal of the Health Sector is to provide an
adequate and effective health service to the entire population of the BVI,
and delivery of such services in an efficient manner is the main
objective.
Currently the health services are administered by the
Health Department which has two operational arms; Peebles Hospital and
Community Health Services.
Main Developments of the Health Sector during the last
thirty years
- Peebles Hospital
The main structure of the present hospital was
completed in 1926. It was described as a cottage hospital with sixteen
beds (16) and six (6) cots. Five of the adult beds constituted the main
ward and were housed in what was described as "a dark and gloomy
room". Two of the latter were blocked throughout the year by
chronically ill patients.
Since the 1940s the building has been the subject of
numerous renovations and extensions, the latest of which were completed
in 1982. At present, the hospital is a three-storey building with a
capacity for 44 beds. In 1996 sixteen physicians service the territory,
94 nurses (seventy-two trained nurses and twenty-two assistant nurses),
five laboratory technicians, two pharmacists, two radiologists, one
physiotherapist, as well as a hospital administrator and many support
staff.
Specialist medical services are available in general
surgery, anesthesiology, pediatrics, obstetrics and gynecology, internal
medicine, ophthalmology and dermatology. X-ray, ultrasound, medical
laboratory, physical therapy and pharmacy services are available.
- Public Health Services
Public Health Programmes began in 1968. This included
mobile child health clinics, and counseling and advisory services for
the mothers in the Road Town Area and rural districts. Antenatal, food
handlers and immigration clinics were held at the Road Town Clinic and
visits were made to schools. Prior to this date there was no organized
immunization programme; today the territory boasts a 95% immunization
coverage for under five years old against diphtheria, pertussis
(whooping cough), tetanus, poliomyelitis, measles, mumps, rubella and
tuberculosis. The infant mortality rate has been substantially reduced
during the past thirty years
In 1990, Public Health Department split into two
fundamental units. Hospital and Community Health Services. At present,
Community Health Services deliver health services on a regular basis
through a comprehensive network system which include one Health Centre
in Road Town and eight (8) district clinics: four (4) in Tortola, two
(2) in Virgin Gorda, one (1) Jost van Dyke and one (1) Anegada. Other
services provided by Community Health Services include Environmental
Health, Mental Health, Health Education, Dental Health and Nutrition
Services.
- Environmental Health
Thirty years ago, the Environmental Health Unit was
staffed by one Public Health Inspector and its main focus was solid
waste management and investigation of nuisance complaints. The only
legal instrument for enforcing public health measurements was the 1950
Public Health Ordinance.
Today, the unit is staffed with five (5) Public
Health Inspectors and clerical support. A Public Health Ordinance was
enacted in 1969 and revised in 1976. The 1976 Ordinance confers ample
powers on the Minister responsible for health to make regulations. In
1988, steps were taken to draft new regulations and amend deficiencies
of those held over under the 1976 Ordinance. Following the improvements
other programmes have been developed in Food Hygiene, Vector Control,
Water Quality and Institutional Hygiene.
An important area for the conservation of the
environment was the decision in 1988 to dispose of solid waste through
incineration rather than the traditional method of sanitary landfill.
The new incinerator became fully operational in 1994, and consistent
with this fact and the increased responsibilities, the unit was given
full departmental status the same year. The Solid Waste Department is
responsible for the following operations: solid waste collection and
disposal, operation of the Pockwood Pond incinerator, street and road
cleaning, roadside trimming, ghut cleaning and beautification.
- Mental Health
Prior to 1969, the BVI was totally dependent on the
goodwill of the Government of Antigua for the treatment of persons with
chronic mental illnesses. After a slow start in 1969 a two-bedded unit
was added to the hospital for treatment of mentally ill patients. In
response to the growing need to provide care for people with mental
health problems, the Community Mental Health Programme started in 1972
as follow-up service out of the hospital. It was later expanded and
promoted to become the treatment module for the entire territory. Since
then it has provided essential mental health care and family support
free of charge to the territory.
Health Perspectives in the BVI
The overall goal of the health sector is the provision
of high quality and accessible primary and secondary health care services
to improve the quality of life and the standard of living of the people of
the B.V.I. To accomplish this goal the Government aims to promote high
quality, cost effective services, choice for the public, and as wide a
scope of local services as possible within their technical and financial
capability.
Health Sector development has to be viewed in the
overall context of the BVI economy. The territory has experienced
unprecedented economic growth within the last two decades, fuelled by the
expanding and lucrative tourism and financial services industries, with
concurrent improvements in communication, transportation and standards of
living. This growth has also attracted a large and needed pool of
immigrant labour and placed increased demands on housing, the social
services, the educational system and the health services. Furthermore, as
standards of living have improved, so has the average life expectancy of
the population, resulting in greater incidences of chronic diseases and
disabilities associated with lifestyles and longevity.
These dramatic demographic changes with the attendant
shifts in disease profiles are inflicting new pressures on the health
service sector. Superimposed on this picture are the health needs of a
large tourist population. A successful response will require a review of
both the numbers of providers and the level of skills that these providers
will bring to a rationalized and forward-looking health service in the BVI.
In particular, the critical care services and emergency response
capability of the hospital will demand recruitment and training of several
categories of specialists health care providers.
Health care delivery in the BVI involves the public and
private sectors. Government is the major provider and financier of health
services. Persons requiring care that is not available in the territory
are assisted by referrals overseas for diagnostic and treatment services.
Primary Health Care in the territory is provided by:
one (1) Hospital (Peebles Hospital), one (1) Health Center in Road Town, a
network of eight (8) District Clinics (East End, Long Look, Capoons Bay,
Cane Garden Bay, Anegada, Jost van Dyke, The Valley and North Sound), as
well as two satellite clinics in Brewers Bay and Sea Cows Bay.
Programmes in the clinics especially target mothers and
young children. They include the following: growth, nutrition, and
developmental surveillance, immunization, vision and hearing screening,
school health, antenatal, postnatal and family planning, family life
education, home visiting and AIDS and sexual health counseling. Other
services offered include community mental health, dental health,
environmental health, health education and community nutrition.
In addition there are a growing number of
establishments promoting healthy eating, natural remedies, physical
exercise and traditional therapies such as massage.
Private medical practice is an important aspect of the
health care delivery system in the BVI. All government consultant
physicians and surgeons are allowed private practice on a part time basis.
It is estimated that around fifty percent of the population use private
practitioners in the territory and in neighboring Puerto Rico and the U.S.
Virgin Islands. The Health Information System does not capture these
health incidents and thus an accurate picture of the health of the country
may not be obtainable. Private health care is provided by one (1) private
hospital, two (2) private dental surgeries, two (2) private medical
complexes and nine (9) private physicians.
Bougainvillea Hospital has eight beds and mainly offers
reconstructive surgery services although some general surgery also is
done. The number of admissions in 1991 was 58, and the average length of
stay was 3.5 days; the occupancy rate is 32.0%.
Secondary Health Care is provided at the Peebles
Hospital that offers accident and emergency services, in-patient care on
medical, surgical, pediatric and obstetric wards and through resident and
visiting specialists.
The BVI has no facilities for Tertiary Health Care.
Clients requiring this service are referred to overseas facilities at the
University Hospital of the West Indies, in Jamaica, Queen Elizabeth
Hospital in Barbados, hospitals in Puerto Rico, the United States of
America. There is also a reciprocal agreement with the United Kingdom in
which BVI nationals are able to procure tertiary care. Under this scheme,
5 children received care for the years 1996 and 1997.
CHAPTER 2
ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL INFLUENCES ON THE HEALTH SECTOR
The structure and performance of an economy are
generally among the primary determinants of the effectiveness of a
country’s health sector and the health status of its people. There is
increasing evidence that economies greatly benefit from integrating health
priorities into their development programs and allocating health
expenditures, not only for consumption but also as investments in human
capital. Good health enhances productivity, permits the use of natural
resources that might be inaccessible due to diseases increases enrollment
of children and their ability to learn, and frees up resources that would
need to be spent on treatment of illnesses.
The economic development and income of the BVI, as well
as its generally good public health system manifest relatively good health
status. Improvements in nutrition, sanitation, access to immunization and
family planning have generally contributed to lower mortality rates and
increased life expectancy. The result is a country not plagued by basic
health problems. However, the health system is showing signs of
deterioration, therefore it is increasingly important to recognize the
need to accelerate the process of health reform. However the good
prospects in the economy, the current health structure and financial
organization are now largely unable to adequately and sustainably respond
to the ongoing and emerging challenges related to demographic and social
changes with the framework of resource constraints.
Policy frameworks affect the allocation of resources to
the health and other sectors. In addition, household use of health
services is determined partly by income, education and fertility levels
and partly by the cost of such services, which might be substantial for
those with minimal levels of income. Environmental factors such as
sanitary conditions, access to clean water and living conditions are
largely outside the control of individuals. They are influenced by levels
of investment in economic infrastructure and tend to be severely affected
in times of budgetary constraints with implications for public health.
Greater efficiency in the management of human, physical and financial
resources are other important factors to improve access to health care.
Effective management leads to improve quality of service by establishing
firm agreements among different public/private sector and between health
and other sectors of their respective roles.
Economic Variations and Implications for the Health
Sector
The economy of the BVI is based primarily on tourism
and on the financial services sector, with emphasis on international
business company registration and trust services, although efforts are
being made to diversify the economic base. The per capita GDP has linearly
increased from US$9,492 in 1987, to US$18,875 in 1991 and to US$26,904 in
1996. The territory relies on local revenue and loans from local and
international services to finance its capital and recurrent expenditures.
At this time, aid represents less than 6% of its financial requirements.
For the last five years, the actual recurrent
expenditure on health as well as the per capita recurrent health
expenditure continued to increase. The health expenditure to GDP
fluctuated between 1.31% in 1990 to 1.23% in 1993 and to 1.34% in 1996.
The percentage of recurrent health expenditure to the total recurrent
expenditure showed a gradual decrease from 9.22% in 1991 to 7.57% in 1996
(see appendix 1).
Epidemiological profiles explored in the Caribbean
Regional Health Study (1996), shows that countries in the region with
lower per capita expenditure on health generally displayed higher
incidence of infant mortality and lower levels of life expectancy than
those with higher per capita expenditure. The BVI shows a high per capita
expenditure on health compared to other Caribbean countries. This however,
does not necessarily equate to better health status, which is also
influenced by other factors such as efficient allocation and management of
resources and effective provision for more equitable access to health care
systems. Morbidity and mortality are inextricably linked to environmental
conditions and the life-style decisions of the population.
Unemployment and labour market structures are
constraints for the improvement of the public sector and by extension the
health sector. Unlike other Caribbean countries, especially non OECS, in
which unemployment averaged as high as 15% for the past seven years, the
BVI enjoyed a low rate estimated as 3.56% in 1991 and is not expected to
indicate any significant change for the next years. A survey conducted by
the Canadian Public Health Association in 1985 shows the extent to which
unemployment is directly linked to health status (Darcey, 1986). It is
manifested in several ways: Psychological distress, anxiety and depressive
symptoms, disability, major activity limitations, alcoholism, and
drinking-related problems. The study also documents the wider impact on
marriage, family and social relations. It is increasingly recognized,
especially among OECS countries, the need for programmes to deal with this
issue.
Data from the 1991 census revealed that there were
11,730 persons of working age, which accounted for 72% of the total
population. Of these, 77% formed the labour force, which was comprised of
8,849 employed and 242 unemployed persons. Over the period of 1980 to1991
the labour force increased by 82% with females accounting for almost 50%
of the growth. Women’s participation in the labour force increased from
38.5% in 1980 to 43.6% in 1991. 76.2% of the labour force is employed in
the tertiary sector. Of note is the fact that in 1991 approximately 60% of
the labour force was expatriate, this is attributed to the fact of the
small local population base. The BVI has no National Health Scheme and
therefore a greater burden is placed on the public health system. It means
there is a significant proportion of the population whose health status
will face uncertainties due to lack of appropriate financing schemes. The
majority of the population will tend to seek care at government
establishments when they are chronically affected
Demographic Profile
a. Population
The ability of the health sector to keep up with the
needs of the population is limited due to unpredictable and rapid growth
of the population, the highly uneven distribution of the population
between the islands and the physical limitations due to geography.
Population size, distribution, structure and composition is subjected to
rapid change due to factors such as high rates of immigration and
emigration and a high throughput of tourists.
The 1991 census indicated that the total population of
the BVI was 16,115 persons. The previous census in 1980 documented a total
of 10, 985 persons. These figures represent an increase in population of
5,131 (46.7%) persons and an Annual Average Rate of Growth of 3.48%.
Approximately 65% of this increase was attributed to the net immigration
rate. Since 1980, population growth rates have increased tremendously
compared to 1.41% and 2.83% per annum in 1960 and 1970 respectively. This
growth reflects the increase in the migrant population that has been
attracted by employment opportunities as a result of economic growth in
the territory.
Recent years have seen marked changes in the
distribution of population. Tortola, the largest island, accommodates
approximately 82% (13,233), while Virgin Gorda the second most populated
2,437 or about 15% of the population. During the last two decades, whilst
Tortola and Virgin Gorda have seen an increase in population density,
Anegada and Jost Van Dyke have seen a decrease.
Over the past decades the proportion of the population
under 15 years has declined, while the population of age groups 45-64 and
65 and over has remain fairly constant for the same period. On the
contrary, the percentage of population between ages 15-44 increased by
about 7% between 1980 and 1991 (see table 1). This drastic shift in the
age composition of the population is a result of the high positive
net-migration situation in the country, which has implications for the
level of dependency ratios. The total dependency ratio plummeted from 115
in 1960 to a mere 49 by 1991. While the child dependency ratio drastically
decreased from 103 in 1960 to 40 in 1991, that of the elderly moved from
12 to 9. The decreasing fertility levels, the massive migration in-flows,
and the increasing levels of life expectancy over the decades have all
contributed to this phenomenon.
The changing age structure has important implications
for the kind of health needs and demands that the population is likely to
present to the health care system. Non-communicable chronic and other
degenerative diseases, as well as general care of the elderly will
increasingly require the attention of the health system.
Table 1
Population by Age Group in 1980 and 1991
and Projections for the years 1996 and 2011
|
Age
Groups |
1980 |
1991 |
1996 |
2011 |
|
Male |
Female |
Male |
Female |
Male |
Female |
Male |
Female |
|
00-04 |
664 |
627 |
812 |
799 |
931 |
891 |
923 |
877 |
|
05-09 |
662 |
646 |
729 |
699 |
864 |
854 |
918 |
889 |
|
10-14 |
548 |
588 |
675 |
671 |
776 |
752 |
943 |
927 |
|
15-19 |
503 |
503 |
604 |
615 |
708 |
690 |
964 |
944 |
|
20-24 |
517 |
538 |
741 |
768 |
676 |
657 |
919 |
898 |
|
25-29 |
574 |
546 |
953 |
901 |
860 |
868 |
884 |
832 |
|
30-34 |
490 |
428 |
879 |
853 |
1,050 |
975 |
867 |
814 |
|
35-39 |
380 |
300 |
713 |
677 |
964 |
903 |
843 |
784 |
|
40-44 |
233 |
222 |
593 |
506 |
779 |
717 |
977 |
945 |
|
45-49 |
170 |
188 |
420 |
351 |
620 |
527 |
1,110 |
1,007 |
|
50-54 |
193 |
188 |
280 |
256 |
436 |
353 |
968 |
899 |
|
55-59 |
188 |
135 |
196 |
172 |
284 |
265 |
732 |
691 |
|
60-64 |
140 |
154 |
182 |
171 |
192 |
174 |
551 |
489 |
|
65-69 |
123 |
114 |
176 |
138 |
173 |
164 |
356 |
313 |
|
70-74 |
96 |
66 |
128 |
108 |
153 |
121 |
200 |
204 |
|
75-79 |
75 |
59 |
89 |
85 |
100 |
82 |
110 |
108 |
|
80-plus |
61 |
66 |
92 |
83 |
90 |
88 |
107 |
106 |
|
Sub-Total |
5,617 |
5,368 |
8,262 |
7,853 |
9,656 |
9,081 |
12,372 |
11,727 |
|
TOTAL |
10,985 |
16,115 |
18,737 |
24,098 |
| Source:
Population and Housing Census 1991 and DPU |
Both the labour force and the number of women of
childbearing age are growing at a much faster rate than the entire
population. In 1991, the male population accounted for 51.5% of the total
population while the female population was slightly smaller with about
54.9% being of childbearing age (i.e. 15-44 years).
b. Fertility
The General Fertility Rates showed a marked reduction
since 1970 when they were 134.5 per 1000. By 1980, and 1991, rates had
fallen to 107.2 and 68.01 respectively, and continue to show gradual
decline. In 1996, the rate had fallen to 61.9. The Total Fertility Rate
decreased from a high of 3.57 in 1970 to 1.75 in 1991, that is, below
replacement level of 2.1 births per woman of childbearing age. The rate
has fluctuated between 1992 to 1996. It should be noted, however, that
since around the mid-seventies until present, the number of live births to
native women has been underestimated by as much as 20%. This is due to the
large number of women who travel to the USVI, Puerto Rico and US mainland
to have their children. Between 1970 and 1991, the Age-Specific Fertility
Rates have dropped. Reductions were particularly marked amongst teenagers,
with a drastic fall in Age Specific Fertility Rate from 110.9 in 1970 to
45.7 in 1991. During 1980 to 1991, the per annum rate of natural increase
has remained fairly stable at around 13 per 1000.
c. Birth Rate
During the period from the 1970 to 1980 the birth rate
has fluctuated between 25.7 and 24.8 per 1000 population, and showed no
defined trend. In 1987, there were 263 recorded births, giving a crude
birth rate of 19.1 per 1000. From 1991 onwards, birth rate has stabilized
and shows a slightly downward trend from a high of 18.2 in 1991 to a low
of 15.1 per 1000 in 1996, where 284 births were recorded.
d. Life Expectancy
During the decade from 1970 to 1980 life expectancy at
birth remained relatively stable. Whilst life expectancy showed increases
for the age groups 1-14, and for those 85 years and above, it declined for
the remaining age groups. However, since 1980, the number of persons over
the age of 60 years has steadily increased. In 1991, 7.8% of the
population was above 60 years. In 1990, life expectancy at birth was 76.8
years for females and 73.3 for males.
e. Migration
Migration is the single most important factor that
affects the BVI population growth and structure. Not only does immigration
increase population, but it also affects every aspect of social and
economic life in the BVI. In the 60's and to certain extent the 70's the
BVI, like many other small Caribbean Islands, had been experiencing heavy
emigration, especially between the age group 20-24 years. However, since
the 80’s immigration surpassed emigration resulting in a migrant
population of over 49% of the total population. This significant rise in
migrant population was due to the increase in economic development in the
BVI, which necessitated the importation of labour. The population has
undergone dynamic shifts because of high immigration and emigration rates.
The net migration in 1990 was 364. Immigration by other Caribbean
nationals to the territory has increased, with most immigrants coming from
the English-speaking Caribbean and the Dominican Republic to work mainly
in tourism and construction.
f. Tourism
The number of tourist arrivals has steadily increased
from 316,670 in 1990 to 412,032 in 1996.
CHAPTER 3
TRENDS IN THE HEALTH SITUATION
The health status in the BVI can be described as
generally good. This can be demonstrated by some of the usual health
indicators such as life expectancy, crude death rates, and infant
mortality rates (IMR). Life expectancy rates have increased over the
years, while crude death rates and IMRs have decreased.
The BVI enjoys good immunization coverage when compared
to ten years ago. This, together with a reasonably good public health
system and initiative, has ensured the drastic reduction of many critical
health problems once experienced.
The prevailing social, demographic and economic
conditions previously discussed, such as an aging population, and the
influence of tourism have had implications for the health status and
practices of the population, as well as responses and expectations.
Community health programmes continue to make progress
in the promotion of health and longevity. Immunization for pre-school and
school-leavers is actively pursued and much emphasis is being placed on
school and domiciliary services. Mental Health, Dental Health Care, Family
Life Education and Health Education have become integral units of the
Community Health Services focusing largely on preventive and promotive
health.
Nutritional status of the population is also considered
good, in part due to the purchasing power of the population. Availability
of specific food products may become a problem if local production is not
stimulated. Currently however, poor dietary habits are believed to
contribute to the increasing problems of diabetes and hypertension, though
no reliable statistics are available for confirmation.
The major causes of morbidity and mortality are
circulatory disorders, diabetes mellitus, malignant neoplasms and mental
ill health, including substance abuse. Accidents and minor infections also
make considerable demands on both the private and public health sectors.
These diseases/conditions account for approximately 70 % of all deaths.
Possible explanations for this trend may include poor general dietary
habits, poor diets before and during pregnancy and fetal development, high
levels of immunization coverage, sedentary lifestyles, as well as the
presence of stress-inducing factors.
Epidemiological Trends
The BVI have a health situation, which reflects that of
the rest of the Caribbean region, in terms of the similarity of health
problems that have emerged. These include the increasing incidence and
prevalence of non-communicable chronic diseases, the resurgence of some
communicable diseases and an increase in the incidence of illnesses due to
external causes (violence and injury).
The territory has a relatively young population with an
increasing incidence of chronic disease in adult life. The pattern of
diseases has moved from communicable diseases, especially those of
childhood, to chronic non-communicable diseases and conditions that can be
prevented by the adoption of healthy lifestyles in early life. The major
causes of morbidity and mortality are hypertensive diseases, diabetes
mellitus, malignant neoplasm (particularly breast, prostate, and
cervical), bronchial asthma, arthritis and mental ill health, including
substance abuse. These diseases account for over 70 % of all deaths.
Possible explanations for this trend may include poor general dietary
habits, poor diets before and during pregnancy and fetal development,
early malnutrition, high levels of immunization coverage, as well as the
presence of stress-inducing factors.
Accidents and minor infections make considerable
demands on both the private and public health sectors. The territory has
also seen the resurgence of some communicable diseases such as dengue
fever, and respiratory tract infections. Communicable diseases usually
associated with poverty and poor environmental conditions (tuberculosis
and gastroenteritis) are also on the rise. There is also an increase in
the prevalence of sexually transmitted diseases, and particularly
HIV/AIDS.
Mortality and Morbidity
1. Mortality
Deaths that occur in hospitals are certified by a
medical practitioner and reported to the National Registration Office,
while those that occur at home are reported by district registrars. Given
the small population size it is important to treat mortality statistics
with some caution. Small variation in actual figures each year may
represent large changes in rates per thousand.
The crude death rate fluctuated during the period 1991
to 1995, from low of 4.3 per 1,000 in 1991 to 5.4 and 5.5 per 1,000 in
1992 and 1994 respectively. It showed a slight decline to 4.5 in 1995. It
is likely that the next few years will see some increase in death rates as
the proportion of the elderly population increases. A quarter of the
number of deaths occurs in persons 80 years and over.
The infant mortality rate is subject to considerable
variation due to the small denominator of live births. After 1987, infant
deaths have numbered from 7 in 1987 to 4 in 1996 and infant mortality
ratio in 1987 was 27.0 per 1000 live births. Increases of infant mortality
rates were observed in 1987 and 1989, although the general trend was
downward. Infant mortality fluctuated between a high of five deaths in
1991 and a low of one death in 1995. In 1991 - 1995, of 1,512 total
births, 21 were stillbirths. Of the 1,491 live births, there were 19
infant deaths, 16 (84.2 %) of which occurred in the neonatal period. In
the same five-year period, there were seven deaths in children 1 – 4
years old. These data can be translated into the following average annual
rates for the period: stillbirth rate per 1,000 live births, 13.8,
neonatal mortality rate per 1,000 live births, 10.7 and infant mortality
rate per thousand live births, 12.74. There were four infant deaths in
1996.
During 1991-1995 there were two maternal deaths, one in
1993 and one in 1994. Both of which were due to complications in ectopic
pregnancies resulting in a maternal mortality rate of 13.39 per 10,000
live births for the period.
There were 405 total deaths from all causes (including
ill-defined conditions) during the period 1991-1995 as shown in table
Table 2
Demographic Indicators 1980, 1991, 1995 and 1996.
|
Indicator |
1980 |
1991 |
1995 |
1996 |
|
Crude Mortality Rate |
7.1 |
4.6 |
4.5 |
4.6 |
|
Infant Mortality Rate |
44.1 |
23.1 |
3.5 |
13.9 |
|
Dependency Ratio |
67.0 |
49.0 |
47.8 |
47.6 |
|
Life Expectancy |
69.0 |
74.60 |
74.6 |
74.8 |
|
Total Fertility Rate |
2.8 |
1.9 |
1.8 |
1.9 |
| Source: Development
Planning Unit and Health Department |
Table 3
Principal Causes of Mortality in 1991 to 1995
|
Cause of Death |
Number |
% |
|
Heart Disease |
102 |
25.2 |
|
Malignant Neoplasm/Cancer |
87 |
21.5 |
|
Cerebrovascular Diseases |
42 |
10.4 |
|
Accidents/Injuries |
35 |
8.6 |
|
Pneumonia/Bronchopneumonia |
17 |
4.2 |
|
Perinatal Conditions |
16 |
4.0 |
|
Diabetes Mellitus |
9 |
2.2 |
|
AIDS |
9 |
2.2 |
|
Renal failure |
7 |
1.7 |
|
Alcoholism |
4 |
0.9 |
|
Ill-defined causes |
77 |
19.0 |
|
TOTAL |
405 |
100.0 |
| Source:
Hospital Medical Records |
Mortality data for 1991-1995 show that Non-Communicable
Chronic Diseases have been the leading cause of death accounting for
approximately 60 % of all deaths. In particular heart diseases, malignant
neoplasm and cerebrovascular diseases have ranked in the top three
positions. Accidents and injuries are also major causes of death. The main
implications for this trend is that factors such as affluence, the aging
process and lifestyles may be contributing agents.
2. Morbidity
Although more than 50% of the territory’s population
is estimated to seek medical care from private physicians, available data
on morbidity are from public facilities, and do not show morbidity at
private clinics. Morbidity data is routinely collected at Peebles Hospital
and summarized according to ICD classifications. Health centre and
hospital data indicate that acute respiratory infections, dermatological
problems, and gastroenteritis are important causes of morbidity among
children. Mental disorders and injuries stand out among adolescents and
adults; and circulatory disorders (hypertension, ischaemic heart diseases,
congestive heart failures), diabetes mellitus, and degenerative diseases
are major causes of ill health among the elderly.
Table 4
Principal Causes of Morbidity (Hospitalization) in 1996
|
Cause of Hospitalization |
Number |
|
Asthma |
97 |
|
Hypertension |
92 |
|
Diabetes Mellitus |
66 |
|
Psychosis |
62 |
|
Bronchopneumonia |
56 |
|
Ischaemic Heart Diseases |
55 |
|
Abortions |
55 |
|
Congestive Heart Failure |
50 |
|
Diarrhea |
47 |
|
Acute Upper Respiratory Infections |
45 |
|
TOTAL |
625 |
| Source:
Hospital Medical Records |
a. Communicable Diseases
There have been no major outbreaks of communicable
disease in the BVI in the last eight years.
- Vaccine Preventable Diseases: The Expanded Programme of Immunization
covers six diseases: diphtheria, poliomyelitis, pertussis, whooping
cough, measles and tuberculosis. During the last years there have been
no cases of vaccine preventable diseases. Of the target population in
1996, 292 infants (from 0-12 months), 100 % received a full course of
DPT, three dozes of oral trivalent poliomyelitis vaccine and MMR
(measles, mumps and rubella)vaccine. Coverage for BCG was also 100%.
- Vector Borne Diseases: No cases of malaria or yellow fever have been
reported in the last 10 years. Sporadic cases of dengue occur. In late
1995 to the first quarter of 1996, 37 cases were reported. Since then,
a few isolated cases were reported. There was no reported case of
leptospirosis, plague or encephalitis.
- Respiratory Infections: Acute respiratory infection is a major cause
of admission to hospital of children under 15 years. In 1996, 32
(71.1%) out of 45 patients were under five years. There were no deaths
from bronchopneumonia in this age group.
Seven cases of tuberculosis were reported during
1992-1996. Three of these cases were reported in 1996.
- Enteric Diseases: Gastroenteritis is identified as a major cause of
morbidity in children. This condition was a major cause for persons
seeking care in the emergency room in 1996. There was one death from
gastroenteritis in 1996 and no deaths from this cause in the previous
two years. Hospital admissions for gastroenteritis show a general
increase from 1990 to 1996. There were no cases from 1990 to 1994, 3
in 1995 and 47 in 1996. There has been no case of typhoid since before
1981. One case of viral hepatitis was reported in 1995. Food poisoning
is uncommon except for illness of ciguatera, of which there was an
average of 22 admissions over the last three years. The food
handler’s and immigration clinics revealed thirty-six positive tests
for helminths from an attendance in 1996 of 1,412 and 1,116
respectively. No cases of cholera have been reported
- Sexually Transmitted Diseases: Data relating to sexually transmitted
diseases gives an inaccurate picture of STD situation as many infected
persons are treated by private practitioners who are reluctant to
report cases. The ready access and utilization of service in the US
Virgin Islands and other places to preserve anonymity further
exacerbates the problem. Between 1985 and December 1997, 47 persons
were reported as being HIV-positive. Of this number, 19 were reported
as having full-blown AIDS; 15 of whom have since died. The male to
female ratio among the 19 AIDS case was 2.1:1. Heterosexual
transmission was the major route of infection with 16 (84%) cases
assigned to this category. A recent HIV sero-prevalence study
conducted in February 1996 to August 1997 revealed no positive HIV
cases among the 408 pregnant women tested. Recent data on other STDs
are not readily available.
b. Non-Communicable and Chronic Disease.
The following statistics are based on data over three
years 1994-1996:
After mental illness, diseases of the cardiovascular
system and diabetes mellitus are the most common causes of hospitalization
in the BVI. Cardiovascular disease, including ischemic heart disease,
acute myocardial infarction, cerebrovascular accident (stroke) is the most
frequent cause of death. The leading causes of death, all ages are: acute
myocardial infarction, other diseases of the circulatory system, malignant
neoplasm, cerebrovascular disease, pneumonia other diseases of the
respiratory system.
Hospital morbidity statistics reinforce the conclusion
that cardiovascular disease, cancer and diabetes mellitus are important
health problems in the territory. Cardiovascular disease encompasses
several different diseases of the circulatory system, including ischaemic
heart disease, cerebrovascular disease, hypertensive disease, chronic
rheumatic heart disease, and other forms of heart disease. Since 1993,
admissions for cardiovascular diseases have gradually increased from 102
in 1993 to 113 in 1994 and 159 in 1996 accounting for 10% of admissions in
1996 ; while cancer accounted for 3% of admissions and diabetes mellitus
5%.
There were 77 admissions for diabetes mellitus in 1993,
59 in 1994, 68 in 1995 and 60 in 1996. The percentage of admissions during
this period was 3.5% to 7%. In 1996 there were approximately 350
registered diabetics attending government clinics.
- Mental Health: Mental ill health is a cause of considerable
morbidity in the BVI. The number of active patients attending the
mental health clinic in 1996 was 200. Adult male accounted for 79 and
female 105. There was a total of 16 children. In 1996, fifty- six of
sixty- two hospital admissions for psychotic conditions were
classified as drug induced (marijuana and crack cocaine) psychoses. 44
or 78.5% were between the ages 15-44, 38 were males and 6 were
females. Admissions for other mental conditions were: schizophrenia
15, dementia 5, personality disorders and anxiety and stress reaction
disorders 24. Alcohol abuse resulted in 55 admissions, 47 males and 7
females.
- Accidents and Trauma: Accidents contribute considerably to both
mortality and morbidity in the British Virgin Islands. In particular,
a toll is taken on active men aged 15-64 years. Of the 38 deaths
analyzed in 1991-1995, 33(86.8%) were males of which twenty were under
the age of 40. Eighteen deaths were due to drowning, seven to motor
vehicle accidents, and gunshot (homicide) 6 from among the 38 deaths
analyzed. Hospital statistics also revealed 17 admissions due to motor
vehicle accidents in 1996.
Table 5
Accidents and Trauma 1991 to 1995
|
Causes |
Total |
Male |
Female |
Percent |
|
Drowning |
18 |
16 |
2 |
47.4 |
|
Hanging |
1 |
1 |
- |
2.6 |
|
Motor Vehicle Accident |
7 |
5 |
2 |
18.4 |
|
Falls |
5 |
4 |
1 |
13.2 |
|
Gunshot |
6 |
6 |
- |
15.8 |
|
Burns |
1 |
1 |
- |
2.6 |
|
TOTAL |
38 |
33 |
5 |
100 |
| Source:
Hospital Medical Records |
Specific Health Problems
Analysis by Population Groups
- Maternal and Child Health
The delivery of prenatal care forms a considerable
part of private medical practice. About 25% of pregnant women receive
antenatal care at the Government clinics. Most pregnant women make their
first attendance during the second trimester. The vast majority of
deliveries (about 98%) take place in hospital. Hospital delivery is
actively encouraged and mothers from the out islands come into the
hospital at Road Town.
Based on hospital statistics for 1995-1996, 8% of
deliveries is to mothers aged 15-19 years. Within this group, the
majority of births were to mothers over 18 years. Pregnancy under 15
years is infrequent. There were two maternal deaths due to ruptured
ectopic pregnancies. One occurred in 1993 and one in 1994.
Admissions to the hospital for spontaneous abortions
account for 2-3%, a gradually increasing trend. The number in 1995 was
39 compared to 55 in 1996. Pelvic inflammatory diseases and other
gynecological conditions are important causes of morbidity resulting in
4-5% of total admissions annually.
During the period 1990 to 1995 approximately 28% of
infants born were considered high risk births because of low Apgar
score, multiple births, cesarean sections, low birth weight, and
prematurity.
Of the 19 total infant deaths in 1991-1995, 84.2%
(16) occurred during the neonatal period. The leading cause of morbidity
for children under 5 years was perinatal conditions with 42 admissions,
acute respiratory infection ranked second with 38 admissions. These were
followed by drowsiness (35), bronchopneumonia (31), diarrhoea and
gastroenteritis (27), asthma (25), convulsions and head injuries (25)
and inguinal hernia (18).
The main health problems in children under 5 years
old at health centres/clinics were skin rashes and skin infections,
allergic reactions, gastroenteritis, obesity, and acute respiratory
tract infection.
The nutrition status (Caribbean standard) among
children under 5 years old attending child health clinics in 1991-1995
were: severe malnutrition 0%; mild to moderate malnutrition 2%; normal
77%; obesity 21%. As is shown in this profile, although there are no
cases of severe malnutrition, there is the tendency to overfeed children
resulting in obesity.
The school-age population (5 - 16 years old)
including pre-primary, primary and secondary schools was 3,681 in 1990.
The main health problems among pre-primary and primary students are
dental caries, skin rashes and/or infections, allergic reactions, and
minor injuries. Problems affecting high school students are injuries,
fevers, coughs and colds, allergic reactions, and dysmenorrhea.
Data from the 1991 census revealed that 4.4% (716) of
the population had one form of disability or another. Of this
proportion, 4.6% reported mental retardation, 12.6%, 3.1% and 2.9%
indicated sight, hearing and speech impediments respectively.
"Other impairments were reported by 62.2%".
In 1996, there were 2,230 visits at Family Planning
Clinics by 1654 clients (32.4 % of the female population aged 15-44
years). Approximately 47% were on oral contraceptive pills and just over
25% on injectable contraceptives. Twenty-six thousand (26,000) condoms
were issued, 6.5% of clients were aged 15-18 years. During this period,
277 Pap smears were taken 17 were abnormal, of these 5 required further
medical intervention.
- Adolescent and Adult Health
Mental disorders occurring among adolescents and
adults are mainly related to substance abuse psychoses, and account for
a high percent of hospital admissions. Injuries related to falls, boat
and motor vehicle traffic accidents are also common.
Mental disorders, particularly among those aged 25-
44 years old, ranked highest for hospital admissions from 1991 to 1995.
Diabetes, hypertension, injury, heart disease, and complications related
to pregnancy are other leading causes of morbidity. In 1991, mental
disorders were the leading cause of hospitalization in Peebles Hospital,
with 129 admissions. Pregnancy complications ranked second with 74
admissions, followed by diabetes mellitus with 69, heart diseases with
61, hypertension with 52, and fractures/open wounds with 47 admissions.
Asthma and concussion also were important with 25 and 21 admissions
respectively. It should be noted that patients of all ages are included
in these numbers.
Over the period 1990 to 1996, of the total live
births, births to teenage mothers ranged from a low of 6.25% in 1990 to
a high of 11.38% in 1992. The average age of teenage girls giving birth
has been 18 years from 1990 to 1996 inclusive. The average age of women
aged 15 - 44 years old giving birth over this period was 27.3 years.
Family life education and family planning services are available to
teenage girls.
Hypertension and diabetes continue to be the main
causes of morbidity, particularly in the age group 45 years old and
older: 72% of persons with hypertension admitted to hospital and 80% of
persons with diabetes were 45 years old and older. Cerebrovascular
disease associated with hypertension is a leading cause of mortality.
The main reasons for hospitalization of diabetes are for stabilization
and for treatment of infections, especially those of the upper
respiratory tract.
The rise in deaths from accidents and injury mainly
affects the young and economically active population. The rates peak in
the 20-40 age group, but remain constant thereafter. For the age group
15-44, injury was the leading cause of death during 1991 to 1995.
Data on communicable diseases and sexually
transmitted diseases show that the highest mortality rates for the
former are among the very young and the very old, whilst for the latter,
the highest rates are borne in the 15-29 age-group
- Health of the Elderly
There is a close correlation between age and the
non-communicable diseases previously discussed. Mortality rates for
circulatory disorders (especially heart diseases) and neoplasms in
particular, drastically increase by age 45, and in the age-group 45-64
the rates are 6 to 12 times the preceding age group. By age 65 and over
they are 26-70 times the rate of the 25-44 age group. It is necessary,
however, to examine and separate the effect of aging from the
consequences of exposure to a range of other risk factors.
The main causes of mortality and chronic ill health
in this group are cardiovascular and cerebrovascular diseases and
malignant neoplasms. Arthritis and osteoarthritis are common causes of
hospitalization.
CHAPTER 4
POLICY, ORGANIZATION AND LEGAL CHALLENGES
Management
The Ministry of Health and Welfare bears responsibility
for the planning and development of public and private health care
services. Specifically, the Ministry's role in this regard is to formulate
and coordinate policies relevant to planning and monitoring of the
performance of health care providers. The Permanent Secretary is
responsible for the administration of the Ministry and for supporting the
Minister's policy role. The overall management of Health Services lies
with the Director of Health Services, who is the chief technical advisor
on health and health care issues. Currently the Health Services are
administered by the Health Department, which has two operational arms:
Peebles Hospital and the Community Health Services. These arms are headed
by a Hospital General Manager and a Director of Primary Health Care, to
whom the day-to-day management of health services is delegated.
The Public Health Act provides the statutory means of
promoting and preserving the population’s health, and grants the
Minister Responsible for Health duties, powers, and functions. This
legislation covers areas such as disease prevention, treatment, and
control; health education; environmental health; and the appointment of
advisory boards and public health officers. There remains a need for
significant review and updating of all current legislation. The BVI have
not amended health legislation within the last two decades. There have
been several redrafts of the BVI Medical Act and Allied Health
professionals Act since 1988, but without any finalization and tabling to
bring these amended acts into law. The absence of updated medical
legislation has significant implications for the standard of practice both
in the public and private sector and precludes the setting up of an
impartial Medical Council. This is a matter that deserves the highest
priority.
Planning and Development
This area is coordinated through the office of the
Director of Health Services. Programs are developed for submission through
the budget process in keeping within government policies. There is no
Health Plan within the Health Sector. The last attempt to develop a Plan
was undertaken in 1983 with support from the Pan American Health
Organization.
The overall goal of the health sector is the provision
of high quality and accessible primary and secondary health care services
to improve the quality of life and the standard of living of the people of
the B.V.I. To accomplish this goal the Government aims to promote high
quality, cost effective services, choice for the public, and as wide a
scope of local services as possible within their technical and financial
capability.
The peculiar geography and population distribution in
the territory lends itself well to a system of geographical zoning and
equity-based care. Such a system promotes equal access to care from
divergent points within the territory and emphasizes levels of care and
appropriate referral linkages based on individual need.
The model envisaged calls for two hospital units: a
multi-care facility on Tortola and a Community Hospital on Virgin Gorda.
These hospital facilities would then be linked to Primary Care Polyclinics
in each administrative zone. Other clinics would then feed into these via
a comprehensive referral system.
The referral system will retain its two present
components; local and overseas referral, both of which depend on a strong
emergency medical response and evacuation capability. This capability
would have to be expanded and developed with clear guidelines fore the
diverse scenarios that may obtain from time to time.
Health Promotion and Disease Prevention will be the
central focus in the future health services and an ongoing need for
upgrading the knowledge and skills of all levels of staff in this area is
envisioned. In particular, the nursing cadre will have to be singled out
for special attention because of their ubiquitous role throughout the
territory. The Health Education Division of the Department of Health will
also play a central role in the development and monitoring of promotional
and preventive activities of all units within the department.
Strategic Issues
- Primary health care provisions facilities/ services
- Health financing mechanisms
Challenges
- To move from actions determined exclusively by demand to areas
determined by situational analysis.
- To combine promotional and preventive approaches along with
treatment and recovery, as the objective of services provided to the
individual.
- To emphasize the economic value of life rather than health care as a
right.
Strategic Goals
- To ensure that all programmes reflect a health promotion
orientation.
- To institute the necessary regulatory mechanism to ensure accessible
quality health care.
- To provide comprehensive health care delivery services at the
primary and secondary levels for all citizens.
- To ensure access to appropriate tertiary care for all citizens.
- To develop effective management to facilitate delivery of efficient
and effective health care.
- To develop programmes appropriate to the health care needs of the
population.
- To mobilize adequate resources: financial, manpower, material and
logistical to meet the health care needs of the population.
Health Reform
The British Virgin Islands have an overlay of health
systems inherited from periods of colonialism, which are increasingly
unable to provide affordable, effective and efficient service as well as
respond to ongoing demands. For this reason, the territory, in 1993,
attempted to carry out a health reform initiative. Health reform has been
described as a process aimed at introducing substantive changes into the
different agencies of the health sector, their relationships, and the
roles they perform, with a view to increasing equity in benefits,
efficiency in management, and effectiveness in satisfying the health needs
of the population. This process is dynamic, complex, and deliberate; it
takes place within a given time frame and is based on conditions that make
it necessary and workable. It is ideally a continuous process responding
to dynamic demographic, medical, and economic changes.
The BVI Government agreed to undertake United Kingdom
Government-funded Health Sector Adjustment Project from 1993 to 1996. A
wide range of consultancy assignments were undertaken to examine the
health sector with regards to health status, epidemiology, policy, finance
and planning and human resources. The objectives of the Project were:
- To implement a new management structure and process
- To revise planning approaches and systems
- To revise financing strategies and improved quality of care and
optimized health outcomes.
The results of the project were as follows:
- Agreement and partial implementation of a new management structure
- Undertaking of a number of health sector studies (including
information, health promotion, accident prevention, mental health, and
environmental health), which were accepted by local health managers as
giving them a sound basis for further forward planning.
The Government’s stated policy is to provide both
public and private comprehensive health care, with special focus on women,
children, the elderly, the mentally ill, and the handicapped. The
government is the main provider of acute medical and surgical services to
the population. Government health activities and policies place strong
emphasis on health promotion. The BVI does not have a formulated health
plan. However, the main priorities are:
- Enhancement of hospital services
- Strengthening government primary health care services
- Improving all aspects of environmental health.
Free medical and hospital care is extended to pregnant
women, children, the police, indigents, firemen, the elderly, diabetics,
and the mentally ill. In an effort to strengthen services at the community
level, the Community Health Services Department was established in 1990.
The social services unit of the health department was established and
became operational in July 1991; it is headed by a social worker, whose
primary responsibilities include providing social services support for the
Department, particularly regarding mental health and AIDS prevention and
control programmes.
Health Promotion
Many of the territory’s health problems relate to the
environment and to lifestyle practices, issues that respond especially
well to health promotion. The health care system has begun to focus on
disease prevention, health promotion and community-based care. The health
sector has utilized mainly three health promotion approaches:
- Medical approach, such as screening for breast, cervical and
prostate cancer, immunization and medically managed behavioural
changes (such as substance abuse).
- Behavioural approach, including health education, social marketing
and public policy to support life-style changes (speed limits)
- Socio-economic approach, that is housing and employment.
Other strategies include education, the use of mass
media, policy and legislation development. Intersectoral action has led to
improvement in water supply and quality, an improved housing stock, levels
of income and actions to encourage balanced eating and exercise. Other
issues that still require considerable action include:
- Urban planning and development including housing design.
- Modes of transportation and transportation routes.
- Traffic accident reduction.
- Development of safe playing areas.
- Workplace safety.
- Consumer involvement in social and cultural change.
If maximum health benefits are to be realized, the
structure of Government and Management should be designed in a way that
enables health agencies to comment on the health impact of proposed
policies. Furthermore, Government sectors concerned with topics such as
education, income security, housing, employment, transportation and
communication, and all other controllers of resource used to take account
of health as an essential factor when formulating policy.
The Health Education Unit has expanded from one health
educator in 1988 to one Senior Health Education Officer responsible for
management, one Health Education Officer, one communications specialist,
one audiovisual technician, and two clerical officers.
This division is responsible for the education
component of health promotion, and for communication and information, it
also provides services to other health department divisions and
collaborates with the Department of Education and Culture on school health
matters and with the Government Information Service in disseminating
information to the public. Priority areas have been identified and health
promotion programmes were developed for multi-age groups to provide
education/information on such issued as heart diseases, AIDS and other
sexually transmitted diseases, nutrition, cholera, and environmental
health. Multi-media health promotion is targeted to all community groups,
but especially to vulnerable groups like adolescents and young adults.
Because it lies within the hurricane belt, the British
Virgin Islands has a national emergency organization that coordinates
activities related to disaster management. Community awareness and
information programmes are used to make people aware of the importance of
preparedness. There is an operational hospital response plan in the event
of a natural disaster, and key personnel have been trained in emergency
procedures. There are basic emergency supplies in each district clinic,
and district emergency committees have been set in motion.
CHAPTER 5
THE PROVISION AND UTILIZATION OF HEALTH SERVICES
Coverage
a. Hospital Services
The hospital is fully subsidized by the Government with
little or no cost to patients. The hospital offers acute care services on
three wards (Surgical/Paediatric, Medical, Obstetric), as well as several
special units:- Accident and Emergency, Operating Theater, Out-patient
services, Labour and Delivery rooms, Ambulance services, Sick newborn
nursery, and Psychiatric services.
Data on hospital services reveal that the total
admissions to Peebles Hospital in 1996 were 1,684, representing 8,861
patient days. The hospital has a bed compliment of 44, resulting in a
ratio of 2.3 beds per 1,000 population. The overall bed occupancy rate
averaged 46%. The overall average length of stay was 5.4 days, although
for patients on the medical unit, the average was 10 days, which could be
attributed to care of the chronically ill, the mentally ill, and the
elderly.
The total number of visits at Peebles Hospital
outpatient clinics for 1996 was 19,842 representing a 4% increase over the
1995 figure. Of this total 9,287 visits were to the casualty department
and 8,208 to the emergency room.
There are several technical support services:
- A small physiotherapy unit staffed by one physiotherapist. The unit
offers therapeutic ultrasound, a range of electrical treatments
including Transcutaneous Electrical Neurostimulator (TENS) and
interferential therapy, moist heat and cold therapy, progressive
resistive exercises, manual manipulation and myofacial release,
cervical traction, whirlpool bath, gait re-education, kinetic
activities and massage. In 1996, a total of 381 patients were treated,
most of whom required a minimum of three treatments. Unfortunately,
current constraints (staffing and space) have resulted in less than
optimal quality of services being offered as the public demands grow
exponentially.
- The pharmacy is located in Peebles Hospital and serves the hospital,
health centres/clinics, and the Adina Donovan Home. It is staffed by a
senior pharmacist, a pharmacist and a laboratory/pharmacy trainee. In
1996, 13,979 prescriptions were dispensed; this compares with 9,866,
9,914, and 11,671 in 1993, 1994 and 1995 respectively. Revenue from
prescription drugs is less than 50% of actual cost, since under
Government policy, certain persons are exempt from paying for drugs.
Revenue collected in 1991 for paid prescriptions was US$16,790, and
the cost of exempted prescriptions, US$58,289. There is no
pharmaceutical control authority. The Hospital Pharmacy is the
procuring pharmacy for all Government pharmaceutical supplies. Through
the office of the Director of Health Services, pharmacy is responsible
for the sale and distribution of controlled narcotic substances. There
is a need of upgrading and revision of pertinent legislation.
- The laboratory, which is staffed by a laboratory director and four
laboratory technicians, provides services to the Peebles Hospital,
district clinics, and private physicians. Service is provided in the
following disciplines: haematology, blood banking, biochemistry,
microbiology, parasitology and serology. Tests that not offered in the
above disciplines are referred to laboratories in USVI and Puerto
Rico. In 1996, a total of 32,319 tests were performed in the lab, an
increase of 3,638 over 1995. Technical assistance is provided by the
Caribbean Epidemiology Centre (CAREC), laboratory division. There
exists a need for technical support in biochemistry and haematology as
these areas are not supported by CAREC. Blood banking is ambulatory.
Blood is taken on a ‘needs’ basis. There is a need to upgrade the
blood banking services.
There is no resident pathologist. Surgical pathology
service is procurred from St. Thomas and Puerto Rico. For
deaths/coroners cases requiring post-mortems, services are provided by a
visiting pathologist from St. Thomas. Cytology services (pap-smears and
other diagnostic services) are also provided from labs outside the
territory (Puerto Rico and USA).
- The Diagnostic Medical Imaging Unit (X-ray) is staffed by a senior
radiographer and a radiographer. Services are offered in the areas of
General Radiography - Chest X-ray/Extermination. Special radiographic
procedures, which include HSG, Intravenous pyelogram (IVP),
Fluoroscopy, Venography, Barium Studies and other Contrast Studies.
Abdominal, obstetric and gynecological ultrasounds and very limited
Cardiac Echo 2-D Studies are also offered. In 1996, over 4,500
radiological examinations were performed. 13 barium meals, 11 barium
enemas, 46 IVP, 8 Special examinations, 24 fluoroscopic studies, 887
ultrasonographic exams. Over 150 patients were referred to centers
outside the territory for Echocardiograms and Doppler studies.
- Inadequate expenditure on maintenance of both plant and equipment
results in the decrease of useful life of essential equipment, poor
quality service and frustration for staff concerned. The maintenance
unit is poorly staffed and equipped, reflecting the inadequacy of
resources to this area. It is staffed by a maintenance supervisor and
six officers who perform regular maintenance of mechanical,
electrical, plumbing, and other apparatus in health care facilities.
Additionally, the space allocated to maintenance in the hospital is
woefully inadequate. Servicing of the laboratory equipment has to wait
for technicians from Puerto Rico, which results in delays and
disruption of services.
- In 1996, 33 registered nurses provided continuous acute care
services on three wards, each with different patient care demands as
well as several special units: Accident and Emergency, Operating
Theater, Specialist Clinics, Out-patient services, Labour and Delivery
rooms, Ambulance services, Sick-newborn Nursery. Additionally, to
these nurses provide care to an active psychiatric inpatient service.
Current staff allocations cannot provide basic care for several
special units. On many occasions, assistant nurses and orderlies must
assume the role of qualified (registered) nurses. There is no
alternate source of registered nursing staff for the hospital when
demands are excessive, and it is not possible to mobilize nurses from
other units or areas in the health service when sudden need arises.
There is an urgent need for an increase in the compliment of
registered nurses with the increase in population and demand for
quality service.
- The medical records unit provides information that is vital to the
effective planning and programming of health services. However, as the
demand for information increases, this task has become more tedious
due to the use of an antiquated information system. The promise of an
HBO system for the past 10 years has still not materialized. This has
hampered any effort of upgrading the current manual system.
b. Community Health Services
Pregnant women are encouraged to attend clinic by the
12th week of pregnancy. All clients attending the public health clinic are
seen and examined by the obstetrician, and there are established criteria
for identifying high-risk clients, so that they are detected early and
received prompt treatment. Hemoglobin levels are assessed and those with
anemia are treated. VDRL tests are done and tetanus toxoid is given. A
maternal "passport", which records the status of pregnancy, is
given to clients and used to provide information to health personnel,
particularly between levels of care. In 1991, 98 prenatal clinic sessions
were registered, with 407 attendances of which 19 women were identified as
having high-risk pregnancies.
Pregnant women attending government clinics, as well as
those attending private physicians’ office, are referred to Peebles
Hospital for delivery. The average yearly number of deliveries is 270; all
deliveries are attended by qualified health personnel, 96.7% in hospital
and 3.3% at health clinics by midwives. The total obstetric bed occupancy
rate is 33% to 55%. The average length of stay for normal deliveries is 2
days. Cesarean sections accounted for an average of 18% of deliveries
between 1994 to 1996.
A public health nurse visits the maternity unit at
Peebles Hospital daily to collect information regarding delivery,
management, and discharge of clients. Referrals are made to district
clinics. Postnatal visits are made to homes on the third, fifth, seventh,
and tenth day after delivery.
Mothers and babies return to clinic at 6 weeks for
postnatal assessment; coverage ranges between 95% and 100%. In the Road
Town area in 1990, 432 postnatal visits were made to 150 women. There were
330 mothers who attended postnatal clinics, 27 more than those delivered
in a hospital or health centre; these 27 gave birth outside the territory.
Child health services include developmental assessment
from 0-4 years old, monitoring of nutritional status based on age for
weight, plotting and interpretation of growth chard, and immunization
according to schedule.
The target population under 1 year old in 1996 was 292,
and coverage in the group aged 0-11 months was 100 %. Twenty five percent
of children registered at clinics in 1990 were born outside the British
Virgin Islands. Many of these children are reported to be from the
English-speaking Caribbean and the Dominican Republic.
Upper respiratory tract infections and gastroenteritis
are usually managed at child health clinics through the use of protocols
(oral re-hydration therapy in the case of gastroenteritis).
As part of the school health programme, a child
receives three physical examinations – the first on admission to school
another in middle school, and the final one before leaving school.
Follow-up care is done by nurses and consists mainly of screening for
nutritional, vision, hearing, and other defects. Haemoglobin testing is
done and booster immunizations administered.
Family planning services are offered at the family
planning clinic in Road Town and at district health clinics. There were
1,654 registered clients in 1996 of which 101 were new participants; 277
Pap smears were conducted. Of the clients using this service,
approximately 79% were between 20 – 34 years old and 5.7% between 15 –
19 years old.
Regarding the battle against AIDS, in 1993 the National
AIDS Committee was renamed the National AIDS and Sexual Health Committee,
reflecting current emphasis on sexual health. Since 1987, all blood for
transfusion is screened for HIV. Self-exclusion information for blood
donors has been developed.
Community awareness and education, particularly
targeting vulnerable groups, adolescents, and young adults are key
components of the national AIDS Programme. Private physicians improved
their AIDS and HIV-positive reporting, and there are ongoing efforts to
strengthen and improve data management and epidemiologic surveillance, not
only for AIDS, but also for other communicable diseases.
There are protocols for the management of persons with
hypertension and diabetes, which are the two main health problems in
adults, particularly among those 45 years old and older. There is one
weekly hypertension and diabetic clinic each in Road Town, East End,
Cappoons Bay and Virgin Gorda. Two hundred twenty-six (226) diabetics are
registered island-wide and the majority of which are hypertensive. The
main objective of control and management efforts is early detection,
treatment and counseling to promote behaviour modification and lifestyle
changes A national diabetic association lends support to its members.
Social changes have changed traditional patterns of
caring for the elderly. The Adina Donovan Home offers residential care for
26 senior citizens. Those with health problems are referred to the
hospital or the medical officer assigned to the facility. Public Health
nurses visit the homes of the elderly in their respective districts. There
were 120 elderly persons visited on a regular basis in 1991.
Immigration by other Caribbean nationals to the
territory has increased, rendering the health of immigrants an issue of
concern. In the process of getting settled in home or job, some new
arrivals to move between districts, making it difficult for health
personnel to contact them or provide follow-up care. In 1996, 50 immigrant
clinic sessions were held for 1,116 attendances. In an effort to control
the importation of communicable diseases, persons who immigrate to the
British Virgin Islands are required to produce laboratory test results for
VDRL, HIV, tuberculosis, ova and parasites.
Regarding oral health, the dental unit is located in
Road Town and is staffed by a dental officer, a dental hygienist, and two
dental assistants, who also visit Virgin Gorda, Jost Van Dyke, and Anegada.
The specific goal of the programme is to reduce the DMF (decayed, missing
and filled teeth) and periodontal disease indices. Services focus on early
diagnosis and prompt treatment to prevent dental disease progression and
recurrence, as well as on providing rehabilitation and limiting
disability.
Oral screening of school children reveals high DMF
indices. The current school-based fluoride mouth rinse programme started
because of high DMF valued in school children and the proven benefits of
fluoride mouth rinsing. In 1991, 15 schools were visited and oral
inspections were carried out; as a result, 350 students were referred for
curative treatment.
The community mental health programme focuses on the
treatment of individuals in their own communities. Home visits to clients
include monitoring of medication, administration of long-acting
medication, family counseling, and the promotion of self-care. Visits also
are made by mental health staff to the prison and geriatric home when
necessary. The drug rehabilitation programme was suspended in 1991 due to
financial constraints.
In 1991, 104 new clients were registered at the mental
health centre, and there were 1,795 client contacts – 1,151 at the
weekly clinics and 644 at home visits. The number of persons being
admitted to hospital shows a decreasing trend, which could be attributed
to the follow-up care in the community and the support received. The
number of hospitalizations was 65 in 1990 and 41 in 1991.
Regarding the operation of medical clinics, a medical
officer is station at the health centre in Road Town. Clinics are held
weekly at East End, Long Look, Cane Garden Bay and Anegada, twice a month
in Jost Van Dyke and Capoons Bay. There is a resident doctor on Virgin
Gorda, where medical clinics are held four times weekly and once weekly at
North Sound. Most persons seen at medical clinics are children and older
persons who have been referred by the nurse or who are self-referrals. In
1991, 294 medical sessions were held and, 642 persons were seen.
c. Environmental Services
These services come under the responsibility of the
Ministry of Health. The environmental health department’s main
responsibilities include water quality surveillance, institutional hygiene
through bacteriological sampling and analysis, inspection and surveys of
commercial water treatment and processing plants, periodic chlorine
testing of the municipal water supply, institutional sanitation, food
sanitation, and vector control.
The municipal water supply is administered by the Water
and Sewerage Authorities, which fall under the Ministry of Communication
and Works. The department maintains laboratory services and monitors the
bacteriological quality of the water it produces. Water samples collected
from domestic systems show various levels of contamination from time to
time. Samples collected by environmental health officers are analyzed by
the water and sewerage technician, but a lack of lab facilities within the
Public Health Department makes it difficult to carry out routine water
quality surveillance. The Water and Sewerage Department also chlorinates
the municipal water supply.
The Ministry of Natural Resources’ Conservation and
Fisheries Department watches over marine environment. Water in several
recreational bays is examined bacteriologically by a technician of the
Water and Sewerage Department in collaboration with the Conservation and
Fisheries Department; high bacterial counts are sometimes reported.
Because there are no requirements for holding tanks,
yachts discharge into the ocean. Septic tank effluent from houses near the
shoreline also often is discharged into the sea. Inadequate public health
legislation allows raw sewerage to be discharged into coastal waters from
Road Town sewerage, hotels, marinas and other tourists facilities, and
houses build near the sea.
Groundwater pollution threatens the quality of the
water supply. In East End and Long Look septic tanks that are not
functioning because of poor construction and nature of the terrain, cause
serious environmental pollution.
Deliberate dumping of used motor oil and animal waste
also contributes to the pollution. Leachate from open dumps also is a
hazard, but the extent to which groundwater and the marine environment are
affected has not yet been determined. The 1991 enactment of the Coast
Conservation and Management Act broadened the legal base for further
control.
In 1991, the Environmental Health Department launched a
water quality surveillance and institutional hygiene programme to monitor
water supplies and ensure basic sanitation in public institutions. The
programme involved the medical certification of water bottling company
employees and others who sell drinking water, as well as periodic sanitary
surveys to detect possible sources of public water contamination and the
monitoring of the bacteriological quality of water in schools, water
companies, the public water supply, hospitals hotels, and restaurants. In
1991, the survey found that all 29 schools inspected had satisfactory
conditions, although one of the five commercial water supplies inspected
was found to be deficient.
Groundwater was the main source of water supply, the
construction of reserve osmosis desalination plants have substantially
increase the |