POSITION PAPER
ON
Population and
Development
The British Virgin Islands, as the name indicates, is a
dependent territory of the United Kingdom, comprising of 60 islands, cays
and rocks located in the Eastern Caribbean some 100 kilometres to the east
of Puerto Rico. The economy is dominated by tourism and
international financial services. Consequently, 95% of our national
disposable income is derived from services. Our economy, in terms of
gross domestic product, has grown threefold since 1984 necessitating
import of labour at all levels of skills. Generally, African
descent in combination dominates the ethnicity with the immigrants of
European decent forming a small minority. Culturally, we represent
the entire spectrum of the Caribbean through immigrants from French,
Spanish and Dutch speaking countries. Like most Caribbean countries,
we are very much exposed to and aspire for the Western industrialized
countries way of life brought through tourism, satellite,
telecommunications, and trade.
Being a country of serene islands spread out over a
large water, area we are more so a marine country with water-based
tourism, particularly yachting and diving, being the prime tourism
activities. Given this scenario sustainable use of
environmental assets, marine or land, is the preferred and only option.
Sustainable development in the context of natural assets preservation and
management has been a key feature in government's approach to macro
management of the country as indicated in our National Report submitted to
the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development (UNCED) in
Rio de Janeiro last year.
Our commitment is to the protection and sustainable use
of natural assets for our current and future generations is further
manifested in our formulation of a National Physical Development Plan with
assistance from the United Nations Committee on Human Settlements (UNCHS).
The socioeconomic, environmental and demographic
situation has been characterized by rapid change and complexities driven
primarily by increased economic activity (oriented around extensive use of
natural assets) which of course is the basis for imported (through
migration) labour. This migration of workers and their dependents exerted
pressure on the social infrastructure and services to a point where they
are operating at a capacity and, as well, the traditional problems
associated with cultural and ethic mixing of population factions. The
following demographic analysis is presented in this contextual framework.
Population trends during the 1980's was highlighted by
a large flow of immigrants consisting mainly of workers, accompanied in
some cases by their dependents, in response to increase for labour which
the domestic labour force could not supply due to inadequate numbers and
the lack of the range of skills demanded. Of course, this accelerated
increase in the demand for labour resulted from a sustained and expanding
increase in economic activities mainly in tourism, construction,
international financial services,- transportation and the communications
sector of the economy from 1985 onwards.
During the last decade, the population increased some
61% with more than 80% of this increase being classified as migration. In
fact population changes attributable to migration moved form net outward
migration in 1980 the three (3) times that figure in net migration inflows
in 1991. The age and sex structure of the population is distinctly
different from that of many countries in the Caribbean sub region in that
a rapid depletion of persons after the age twenty (20) because of the
absence of migration. The unusual age structure is explained by the rapid
economic transformation of the country from agricultural production to a
service economy oriented around tourism and financial services.
The older cohorts show a pattern of heavy emigration as
in other Caribbean countries the younger cohorts have emigrated less
recent emigration has been balanced and surpassed by substantial
immigration of young adults mainly from larger countries of the Caribbean
(Dominican Republic, Jamaica, Guyana, etc.). Additional characteristics of
the age distribution is the absence of a bulge in the pyramid at older
ages that results from heavy retirement return migration by persons who
emigrated to find work earlier and little undercutting of the pyramid at
younger ages that would indicate substantial fertility decline in recent
years.
Differing from many countries in the sub-region, the
sex ratios by age groups do not show a steady decline with age as a
consequence of generally lower mortality of females than males at all
ages. Instead, the pattern is irregular, probably as a result of sex
selecting immigration and may be to some extent the,small numbers
involved. It is very unusual to find at almost all ages above 50 years the
sex ratios are above 100, thus indicating that there are more males than
females even in the oldest age groups.
A broader comparison of the population age distribution
from 1960 to 1991 shows that the population of the population under 15
years has declined successively form 48% to 24%. Correspondingly, the
population of the groups 15-44 has risen from 35% to 55% during the same
period and proportion age 65 and over has remained more or less constant.
The median age of the population has consequently rise from 16 to 24
years. Among other things, these changes mean that both the labour force
and the number of women of child-bearing age are growing at a much faster
rate that the overall population as a result of the net inflow of
immigrants to the economic circumstances.
On the other hand the school population has grown
relatively slowly so that although between 1960 and 1990 the total
population grew by 103%. the population under 15 grew by only 15%. In
contrast, the number aged 45 years and over has increased by 128% slightly
higher than the increase in total population. The conventional dependency
ratio differs remarkably from the regional norm is that is much more
favourable because of immigration policies in respect of dependents.
accompanying migrant workers. In fact, the dependency ratio triples when
dependents declared by migrants on their applications are taken into
consideration.
The British Virgin Islands have, five (5) major
population centre or islands and 80% of the population live on the largest
island which accounts for 40% of the land mass. the third largest island,,
representing 15% of the land mass- and housing 60% of tourism plant,
accommodates about 15% of the population. The distribution of population
must be viewed in the context of the British Virgin Islands being a marine
or water country with a mature area more than 20 times the land mass.
The fertility ratio among citizens is approximately
one-third that of immigrants due on the one hand to immigration policies
requiring repatriation of school age children born to immigrants not
properly documented and on the other hand the exposure of female citizens
to birth control methods and the desire of Western Industrialized
countries to have fewer children for economic and other reasons. Overall
in line with the trend observed in other countries of the region the
fertility rate is declining. However, the major difference is that the
rate of net in migration is increasing to cope with the demands for labour
brought on by increased economic activity.
Implications for Population Policies and Strategies
In view of the demographic, social, economic and
environmental situation of the British Virgin Islands described above the
implications and imperatives for population policies and strategies within
the context of integrated development are obvious. While my country
subscribers fully to the right of individuals to determine the size,
timing and location their families together with the right to live
anywhere in the country, government seeks to administer its responsibility
for promoting and maintaining sustainable development within the context
of changing productivity patterns with social equity and within the
limits, constraints and parameters of our natural assets base.
Government, in having to administer social justice in a
country 49% foreigners, seeks to address the full range of socioeconomic,
environmental and population issues and concerns simultaneously rather
than sequentially. Our conviction is that in order to avoid repercussions
traditionally associated with imbalanced sectoral growth and ignoring of
the population issues we must plan in integrated manner for providing the
full range of social services including but not limited to health care,
education, social welfare, social security and housing. Our development
objective is the betterment of humans in all his dimensions. Our social
policy, as part of an overall integrated policy, will focus an improvement
of the physical, social and economic environment in qualitative and
quantitative terms. Policy will focus on social equity, the status of
women, children and foreigners and social welfare for all our population
whether acquired through vital events or immigration.
The demographic trends together confirmed investment
intentions of both the public and private sectors suggest that a large
number of new job seekers and immigrants will pose serious population
policy considerations for policy makers. Additionally, particularly with
young job seekers, the mismatch of skills available and demanded, as a
consequence of economic activity, will deepen the situation in terms of
population in its widest sense. Population issues are explosive if the
solution does not focus on resolution of fundamental structural conflicts
and problems bring with them seriously negative social consequences.
It is abundantly clear that the role of the public
sector has to be widened if it is to continue in its role as a
facilitation for the development of the private sector has to be widened
if it is to continue in its role as a facilitation for the development of
the private sector, and protector of the right of its citizens to basic
human needs and benefits of progress and insurer of the basic rights of
all individuals under its control.
In environmental terms, the British Virgin Islands is
true a marine country with an exclusive economic zone extending some two
hundred miles in the Caribbean sea in the choice areas of international
fishing fleets and, as well, nearer to home, serving as the home of
yachting and driving making up the bulk of our tourism activities. This
means that tourism competes with fisheries for the use of the same fragile
coral reefs, sunken wrecks made into reefs for fish breeding and the deep
root water for catching pelagic species to feed tourists.
Land-based tourism in form of totals, guest houses and
villas compete with construction for use of the limited flat land to build
homes and tourism plants, while agriculture for fertile land and again
with tourist for use of white sand. Further the need for reclaimed land is
essentially a mountainous country competes with fish hatching grounds for
mangroves and watershed or we areas.
Socially, the country seeks to manage a cultural mix of
Spanish and English Caribbean nationals with an ethnic mix of Africans,
Europeans and East Indian integrating these cultural and ethnic
diversities in itself a challenge to such a small country in the absence
of an adequate framework institutional and economic infrastructures.
In essence we observe demographic factor pushed by
development of social and economic infrastructure, tourism plant, housing
and institutional infrastructure are exerting pressure and the physical
environment in competing for the use of scarce natural and human
resources.
In view of the socio-economic, environmental and
demographic situation, my government, through a strategic visionary
approach is fully committed to the integration of population in our
development planning process now highlighted by the formulation of a
National Integrated Development Plan and with assistance from the other
relevant specialized UN agencies. By integration I mean the explicit
consideration of population variables in development planning By taking
into account both the impact of population factors on development and
implications of development goals, strategies and programmes for
population variables.
Preliminary demographic demographic analyses have
indicated that migration has been the most critical population variables.
It must be remembered that our systems in the Caribbean sub-region are
much smaller, more volatile, more vulnerable to external shocks and more
robust to changes in global conditions. In the sub-region there is the
same desire for sustainable development and changing productivity patterns
with social equity as our larger regional neighbours but our problems in
respect of population are more explosive, and can be more devastating. Of
course you recognize that I am about to request that migration, with its
various impacts, influences and outcomes be considered as the major area
for immediate, comprehensive and sustained attention on the sub-regional
level.
In recognition of important role of population in the
social, economic and environment dynamics of the Caribbean sub-region,
through you Mr. Chairman, I am appealing to concerned specialised UN
Agencies to maintain the presence of population analysis skills in the
sub-region and, further, to provide resources and effectively support a
migration study of consequence for the region, and Mr. Chairman, given
population dynamics of my country, I offer it to the specialised agencies
and area for a pilot study on migration in the sub-region to a prelude to
a larger sub-regional study.
While I still have the floor, Mr. Chairman, I must
congratulate the UNFPA for responding so promptly to a need assessment
request made by my country to assist with background information, data,
policies and strategies in respect of NIDP 1994-1998. Further it would be
remiss of me if I did not congratulate and express my sincerest
appreciation to ECLAC/CELADE Demography Unit in Port-of-Spain for the
yeoman assistance given to the region and my country in the area of
demography.
|