The Status of
Women
In the British Virgin Islands
6. ACCESS TO EDUCATION, HEALTH, EMPLOYMENT, AND OTHER
MEANS TO MAXIMIZE AWARENESS OF WOMEN'S RIGHTS AND THE USE OF THEIR
CAPACITIES
"Happily as our population increases, the role
and status of women has changed and improved, especially in the areas of
employment, education, health and other social standings". (B.V.1.
National Report for the International Conference on Population and
Development (ICPD), 1994:21)
In this section of the document an examination of the
implications of that statement will be made. The dearth of
gender-sensitive statistical research has made this analysis more
difficult, but some valuable insights have been obtained from the plethora
of reports which have been made available to the researchers.
In their assessment of the current status of population
policy, the presenters of the ICPD report (1994) make this comment:
Immigration and labour issues, being the more
transparent and volatile ones received more attention than fertility,
mortality, health and education issues, which were admittedly of lower
profile. (p.23).
We now go on to examine these areas to determine what
the present day reality is for women of the B.V.1.
EDUCATION
A review of the education system in the BVI was
conducted in 1988. Unfortunately, there was no gender sensitivity in the
objectives of the review, so consequently the information which was
obtained was related to the general status of education, and the decisions
which were taken were also general in nature.
Perhaps this decision not to assess the education
system to determine the differential effects on males and females was the
product of a feeling that there was equality with regards to the treatment
of the sexes and the achievement of the sexes in the education system.
Rita Frett-Georges in a review of the mental health
status of women pointed out that "there is no general perception of
women being disadvantaged or seriously discriminated against" (1986,
p. 7). One must assume that that general perception probably held true for
education as well In 1988, because the recommendations of the review were
advising action on concerns related to teacher training, curriculum
development, technical co-operation and technical and vocational training.
Table 6:1 indicates that in 1980 and 1991 women formed 48.9 per cent of
the population respectively.
Population - Table 6:1
| YEAR |
# FEMALE |
% FEMALE |
# MALE |
% MALE |
TOTAL |
| 1970 |
4541 |
47.0 |
5131 |
53.0 |
9672 |
| 1980 |
5368 |
48.9 |
5617 |
51.1 |
10985 |
| 1991 |
7850 |
48.7 |
8258 |
51.3 |
16108 |
| TOTAL |
17759 |
48.3 |
19006 |
51.7 |
36765 |
Source: ICPD Report 1994
The above figures indicate that men outnumbered women
by an average of 3.4 per cent over the twenty year span. Table 6:2, which
demonstrates enrolment by gender, mirrors the overall population ratio in
primary school enrolment for 1981 but females are slightly
underrepresented in 1988 (46% to 54%). However, the statistics for'
secondary education point to an interesting contrast, as females in 1981
outnumbered males in proportion to their ratio in the population by
fourteen per cent. Statistics from 1992 demonstrate that females outnumber
males in enrolment at secondary and tertiary levels. At secondary level
the difference is 6 per cent and at tertiary level it is,10 percent.
TABLE 6:2
ENROLLMENT BY GENDER AND LEVEL
| LEVEL |
# F |
% F |
#M |
% M |
TOTAL |
PRIMARY
1981
1984
1988
1992 |
838
719
1192
838 |
49.0
47.8
46.0
82.6 |
877
786
1383
952 |
51.0
52.2
54.0
53.2 |
1717
1505
2575
179 |
SECONDARY
1981
1984
1992 |
495
533
617 |
57.0
56.0
53.1 |
381
418
545 |
43.0
44.0
46.9 |
875
951
1162 |
TERTIARY
1981
1984
1992 |
2
0
190 |
22.2
0.0
55.1 |
7
0
155 |
77.8
0.0
44.9 |
9
0
345 |
Sources: 1980-81 Population Census; ICPD Report 1994;
Country Paper on Financing Education 1993
Table 6:3 addresses graduation by gender and level.
TABLE 6:3
GRADUATION BY GENDER AND LEVEL
| LEVEL |
# F |
% F |
#M |
% M |
TOTAL |
| PRIMARY 1981 |
1723 |
46 |
2054 |
54 |
3777 |
| SECONDARY 1981 1981 |
1054 |
53 |
934 |
47 |
1988 |
| UNIVERSITY 1981 |
202 |
43 |
272 |
57 |
474 |
| TECHNICAL 1981 |
646 |
42 |
882 |
58 |
1528 |
Source: 1980-81 Population Census, BVI
Although females are underrepresented by 2.9, as they
graduate from primary school, based on their ratio in the population in
1980, graduation figures from secondary school in 1981 show that they
exceed the male secondary school graduates proportionately. However, males
again surpass them in university and technical school graduations in 1981.
Table 6:4 shows that although we see males gaining more degrees we find
that women are gaining more diplomas.
TABLE 6:4
QUALIFICATIONS BY GENDER
| |
# F |
% F |
#M |
% M |
TOTAL |
| DIPLOMAS |
161 |
52 |
147 |
48 |
308 |
| DEGREES |
126 |
38 |
206 |
62 |
332 |
Source : 1980-1981 Population Census, B.V.1.
Figures from the Ministry of Education and Culture
indicate that women were awarded 63.9% of all scholarships from 1989 to
1992.(O'Neal, 1994). However, most of these scholarships were for studies
in business, education, and medical care. During that period ten
scholarships were awarded for engineering studies but none of these went
to women.
TABLE 6:5
SCHOLARSHIPS BY AREA OF STUDY AND SEX, 1989~-1992
| AREA OF STUDY |
MALE |
FEMALE |
AREA OF STUDY % AGE |
SEX % AGE FEMALE |
| Business, Economics, etc. |
12 |
25 |
25.2 |
67.6 |
| Medical Care |
6 |
25 |
21.14 |
80.6 |
| Education |
4 |
17 |
14.3 |
81.0 |
| Engineering |
10 |
0 |
9 |
|
| Humanities |
4 |
3 |
4.8 |
42.9 |
| Computer Science |
2 |
6 |
5.4 |
75.0 |
| Agriculture/Fisheries |
1 |
1 |
1.4 |
50.0 |
| Other |
14 |
17 |
21.1 |
54.8 |
| Total |
53 |
94 |
147 |
63.9 |
Source: BVI Country Paper for UWI Seminar on Financing
Education, 1993
This discrimination in scholarships, combined with the
fact that census figures still find women in clerical and other
non-management fields, indicates that even today, although women are
gaining more scholarships, they continue to he predominantly in the areas
in which women have traditionally served. Census figures would probably
still find men getting more degrees today while women graduate at a lower
level with diplomas. In fact even in the field of education, we note that
in the BVI most teachers are women and even though women are the
principals of primary schools, "top administrative posts in the
secondary and tertiary are, for the most part, held by men. Out of the
three public secondary institutions in the territory one is headed by a
woman, while the dean, president and vice-president of the community
college are men." (Women's Desk, 1994). The socialization messages
which are being transmitted to children by this clear gender
differentiation in job allocation undoubtedly predisposes them to
perpetuate the pattern.
TABLE 6:6A
TEACHER/PUPIL RATIO FOR ALL SCHOOL LEVELS
| YEAR |
PRE-SCHOOL |
PRE-
PRIMARY/
PRIMARY |
SECONDARY |
SPECIAL
* |
TOTAL |
| 1985 |
|
20.20 |
15.03 |
|
18.04 |
| 1988 |
|
20.64 |
13.42 |
|
17.68 |
| 1990 |
15.20 |
18.57 |
12.77 |
7.20 |
15.75 |
| 1992 |
16.24 |
16.24 |
12.33 |
8.55 |
13.76 |
Source: BVI Country Paper for UWI Seminar on Financing
Education, 1993
TABLE 6:6B
TEACHER/PUPIL RATIO BY GENDER AND LEVEL
| LEVEL |
# F |
% F |
#M |
% M |
TOTAL |
PRIMARY
1988 |
88 |
85 |
16 |
15 |
104 |
SECONDARY
1988 |
58 |
68 |
27 |
32 |
85 |
Source: National Report for ICPD 1994
Table 6.6A shows the teacher pupil ratio for all school
levels during 4 years, while Table 6:6B shows the gender analysis of that
ratio. Women are clearly the ones who were responsible for education at
primary and secondary levels in 1988, and it would not be presumptuous to
conclude that they are also over represented at preschool and pre-primary.
Although there is little statistical information
available for comparisons to be made between the status of women in the
1980's and the present, the foregoing evaluation indicates that the
obvious gains which have been made by some women are not a reflection of
the reality for most women. While opportunities for tertiary education are
now being presented more frequently to women who, statistics indicate, are
more academically qualified than their male counterparts are to receive
them, the choices made by women continue to relegate them to positions
subordinate to men.
HEALTH
A lot of attention has been focused on health in the
B.V.1. and many documents, some of them annual reports and others more
broadbased, have addressed this issue. The territories' unique population
profile consists of 49.9% persons of foreign birth which accounted for
8,032 of its 16,108 inhabitants in 1991. This statistic has led to
concerns about the potential conflicts between population, environment and
development. Government's response to this situation has led to the
implementation of immigration laws and policies to reduce the number of
children born to foreign nationals during their stay in the B.V.1.
(National Report, ICPD,1994). That publication further affirmed the
measures government put into place. In addition to the local Immigration
Act, the British Nationality Act was also a means of population control.
There were also health related measures:
... institutionalizing family planning and
promoting reduced fertility were at the centre of the strategy to
avoid economic driven immigration creating severe and unmeetable
demands for social services in health, education and welfare.
(National Report, ICPD,1994:22)
This avowed preoccupation with immigration and
population control in the BVI has allegedly led to some discrimination and
some abuse of women without belonger status. Abortions were said to he on
the increase among these women who would be forced to leave the island if
they were known to be pregnant. The "policy is controversial and
negatively affects the health, stability and psychological well-being of
persons involved." (Frett-Georges, 1986). The effects of this
discrimination will he further discussed in reference to violence against
women.
A recent publication published in this year 1994 by the
BVI Ministry of Health "A HEALTHIER FUTURE FOR BVI" demonstrates
the government's commitment to providing good health services. This
document details a three-year programme of health reform. The report does
not specifically address-the needs of women as it is written in more
general terms and perhaps is reflective of what is cited in the National
Report for the ICPD as the overall development strategy of the BVI
government "...to enable the people to live longer, healthier and
more productive lives."(p.30) let us then take a look at the
statistical data as it pertains to this strategy.
Table 6:7 demonstrates that life expectancy for women
has continued to be longer than that for men over the past decade. This is
in keeping with universal statistics which typically have women living
longer.
TABLE 6:7
LIFE EXPECTANCY AT BIRTH BY GENDER
| |
FEMALE |
MALE |
| 1983 |
74.8 |
74.6 |
| 1985 |
75.3 |
73.7 |
| 1992 |
75.7 |
74.0 |
Source: National Report for ICPD 1994
Maternal mortality has been reported to be 0.0. Only one death was
reported in 1987 due to toxemia and inadequate antenatal care, and none
have been reported since. (Harney, 1992, and Public Health Annual Report,
1987).
TABLE 6:8
CRUDE DEATH RATE
| YEAR |
MALE |
FEMALE |
| 1983 |
5.0 |
4.9 |
| 1985 |
5.3 |
4.5 |
| 1987 |
7.4 |
4.0 |
| 1992 |
6.2 |
4.5 |
Source: National Report, ICPD 1994
TABLE 6:9
INFANT MORTALITY
| |
FEMALE |
MALE |
TOTAL |
| 1983 |
21.6 |
21.1 |
21.4 |
| 1985 |
15.9 |
17.4 |
16.6 |
| 1991 |
28.0 |
18.8 |
23.9 |
| 1992 |
0.0 |
26.3 |
13.8 |
Source: National Report for ICPD 1994
The infant mortality have been attributed to neonatal
deaths and still birth rates. The leading causes of death have been noted
as premiered and respiratory disease syndrome (Harney et al, 1992). No
explanation has been given for the fact that in 1992, while there was O.O
mortality for females infants, the rate for males was 26.3. The lowered
rate for females has led to a significant decrease in the infant mortality
statistic. The National Report for the ICPD has attributed this
improvement to the free services provided by Maternal and Child Services
for both nationals and immigrants in the 1980's.
Teenage pregnancy which was said to be 6.6% in 1990 has
been noted as one of the non-medical factors which contribute to infant
mortality (Harney et a], 1992). It is Interesting to note that teenage
pregnancies Gave decreased from 17.5% in 1979, to 15.3% In 1985 and 6.6%
in 1990 according to the Hospital Records cited by Harney. Trained
attendants in the persons of doctors and midwives attended to 98% of the
live births in 1987. These statistics are incomplete, however, as they
exclude the children who have been born in the United States Virgin
Islands to mothers normally resident in the BVI. These figures are
unfortunately unavailable.
All reports of immunization records in the BVI have
been positive, as the figure below demonstrate.
TABLE 6:10
IMMUNIZATION RATE 1990 (%), 1987 (#)
| |
1987 # |
1990 % |
| DPT |
1094 |
98 |
| Measles |
106 |
98 |
| Polio |
2263 |
95 |
| BCG |
|
100 |
Sources: Harney et al 1992. Public Health Department,
Annual Report 1987
Child health care covers a well-developed and efficiently
functioning programme of immunization, monitoring. (National Report
for ICPD,.growth and nutrition monitoring. and 1994:2~9).
The above statement is substantiated by the UNICEF
report prepared by Harney et al which states that "there have been no
cases of poliomyelitis for 30 years, no cases of diphtheria, of tetanus in
children or whooping cough for many years; no death or cases from measles
since 1987."
Women in their reproductive years of 15 to 49 years
formed 26.5 per cent of the population in 1980 and 28.8 per cent in 1991
(National Report for ICPD,1994). The total fertility rate for women was
3.1 in 1980 and 2.0 in 1991. (Table 6:1 1)
TABLE 6:11
TOTAL FERTILITY RATE FOR WOMEN
Source: National Report for ICPD 1994
In 1980 teenage births accounted for 12.7 percent of
all births, in 1985 for 15.3 percent and in 1990 for 6.6 percent. Although
these figures have decreased, perhaps due to the intensive family planning
campaign, individuals have expressed a need for a comprehensive adolescent
health programme which would emphasize health education and values and
would seek to build self-esteem through an emphasis on indigenous culture.
Please note again the unavailability of statistics for births in the USVI.
Concern has been expressed about the high number of
spontaneous abortions, as 33% of women of childbearing age appear to be
having difficulty.
The leading causes of death in 1987 were heart disease
and respiratory disease (Public Health, Annual Report, 1987) and this
remained unchanged in 1992. (Harney et al, 1992). Obesity has been a
serious health concern. In 1984, 40% of all women appeared to be affected
as compared to 20% of all men. A related problem of high blood pressure
has also been affecting women almost four times as much as it has been
affecting men (14 percent women, 4 percent men). Women have also been
identified as, the main victims of diabetes. Up to the end of March 1994,
30 cases of HIV/AIDS had been reported to the Public Health Department, 12
of which were women.
Low income women, especially domestic workers who are
usually non-belongers are more often affected by health problems and
stress-related disorders.
The most frequent cause of hospitalization in 1984 and
1989 (apart from normal deliveries') was mental disorders. In 1984 these
totalled 53, of which 21 were female and 32 male (Frett-Georges, 1986)
while in 1987 they totalled 77, of which 23 were female and 54 male. (
Harney et_al, 1992). With regards to the actual numbers of people
diagnosed as psychotic, females, have surpassed males as Table 6:12
illustrates.
WOMEN AND AIDS
Three new cases of women diagnosed with HIV have been
reported to the BVI National AIDS and Sexual Health Programme since the
start of the year. No new male case has been reported to the Programme so
far during 1994.
The AIDS and Sexual Health Programme is now aware of 30
persons in the territory known to be HIV 55 positive since 1987 when the
first AIDS case was reported.
One of the three women with HIV developed AIDS,
accounting for the only reported case of AIDS up to March 1994. The woman
died during this year.
The reported HIV cases this year will have a
significant impact on the male and female ratio of zero to one. So far in
1994 that pattern is continuing.
In a recent edition of the Health Education unit's
quarterly news letter: Fit-For-life, a Medical Specialist, Dr. Everlyn
Fisher said, it-is 10 to 29 times more likely that the women will get
infected during unprotected, heterosexual intercourse in a situation where
the male and female partner appears to be healthy. According to her, women
are far more vulnerable to HIV than men and therefore protecting them
yields more in terms of transmission reduction efforts.
The male and female ratio of zero to one introduced in
fact the BVI during 1993 appears to be continuing this year. This
situation highlights that women have to assume the responsibilities for
their own protection from HIV and other sexually transmitted diseases.
For the period 1987 to May, 1994, 16 males and 12
females have been reported with HIV. Ten such ,persons developed AIDS -
six males and four females. Since 1987, just one case if child under five
years old has been reported to the programme.
Twenty-three persons reported with HIV in the territory
are alive, women account for 11 of them.
TABLE 6:12
MENTAL HEALTH
| |
TOTAL |
FEMALE |
% FEMALE |
MALE |
%MALE |
| 1985 |
94 |
50 |
53.2 |
44 |
46.8 |
| 1992 |
42 |
22 |
52.4 |
20 |
47.6 |
Source: Rita Frett-Georges, 1986; Peebles Hospital, 1992
Domestic violence and sexual abuse including rape
serious implications for health problems for women. In the BVI, 40 female
admissions for injuries were made to hospital in 1991. It is unsure how
many of these were related to violence against women. This area is so
important that it will be dealt with in a subsequent section.
EMPLOYMENT
In 1986, Rita Frett-Georges in her paper on the Mental
Health Status of Women in the BVI found that her data supported Burkes'
1983 statement on the profile of Caribbean women of the middle years.
More than one third of all households in the Caribbean
are headed by women. Women generally constitute about 40% of the labour
force. In some countries whore literacy rates are high they comprise over
50% of the educators, and civil servants. About 50% of the Caribbean rural
population are women who play a major role in agriculture. On a regional
average, however, about 70% of women are employed in low paid, low skilled
job.- art, the rates of unemployment are high in the territories. (Frett-Georges,
1986 p.9)
Table 6:13 below presents figures from the 1991 census
as they relate to single headed households in the BVI. Table 6:14
illustrates the monthly income in those homes by gender.
TABLE 6:13
SINGLE HEADS OF HOUSEHOLDS 1991
| |
FEMALE |
% FEMALE |
MALE |
% MALE |
TOTAL |
| NATIONALS |
552 |
55.0 |
453 |
45.0 |
1005 |
| NON- NATIONALS |
746 |
47.5 |
826 |
52.5 |
1572 |
Source: National Report ICPD
About 20% (260) of the male heads and 24% (315) of the
female heads were employed in managerial and professional positions, while
15% (193) males and 21% (280) females were employed in subordinate
positions. As Table 6:14 shows, females earned less even though they had
higher education
TABLE 6:14
SINGLE HEAD INCOME PER MONTH BY GENDER
| FEMALE |
1092.62 |
| MALE |
1417.32 |
Source: Women's Desk 1994
Although Table 6:13 might appear to refute Burkes'
finding in the Caribbean that more than one third of all households are
headed by women, one must keep in mind the unique population profile in
the BVI which is influenced by 49.9% of foreign born inhabitants. These
women are "actively discouraged from giving birth to children in the
territory by being asked to leave the islands "(Frett-Georges, 1986).
The migration of dependents of imported workers provides an interesting
context for the interpretation of any data regarding families in the BVI.
In fact the researcher is faced with a dilemma because of difficulties in
recording this information faced by persons collecting census information.
The presenters of the national report for the ICPD found that the last
census did not correctly assess the proportion of the population that is
foreign born. They made their dilemma clear in the following statement:
Census information lead us to conclude that the
conventional dependency ratio cannot adequately reflect the true
picture in the BVI as persons on their immigration application
indicate that they have some 8,256 dependents living outside the BVI.
The traditional dependency ratio provides a misleading picture of the
economy in terms of savings ratio, household per capita income, and
spending etc. (National Report for ICPD, 1994 p.20)
Although Table 6:14 shows the monthly income of single
head households by gender, the researchers for the ICPD affirm that such
figures overrate the economic well-being of the BVI as foreign workers
have to remit a significant part of their income to their home country to
support the dependents left there.
Table 6:15 illustrates the number of people in the
labour force according to their gender while Table 6:16 shows the
unemployment rate by gender. From both tables one will observe that men
are more likely to he employed than women.
TABLE 6:15
WOMEN AND MEN IN LABOUR FORCE, % OF POPULATION
| YEAR |
TOTAL |
FEMALE |
MALE |
| 1980 |
45.4 |
38.5 |
61.5 |
| 1991 |
56.4 |
43.7 |
56.3 |
Source: National Report for ICPD 1994
TABLE 6:16
UNEMPLOYMENT RATE % OF POPULATION
| YEAR |
TOTAL |
FEMALE |
MALE |
| 1980 |
4.5 |
6.2 |
3.4 |
| 1991 |
3.3 |
3.1 |
3.5 |
Source: National Report for ICPD 1994
A closer examination of the labour force in Table 6:1 7 demonstrates
that the service industries accounted for more than 80% per cent of
employment in both census years cited.
TABLE 6:17
DISTRIBUTION OF LABOUR FORCE
| CATEGORY |
1980 |
1991 |
| AGRICULTURE |
5.7 |
1.9 |
| INDUSTRY |
14.3 |
17.2 |
| SERVICE |
80.0 |
80.0 |
Source: National Report for ICPD 1994
It is not surprising then that the Gross Domestic product shows that
the greatest increase in economic activity during the years 1985 and 1989
are in areas related to tourism as presented in Table 6:1
TABLE 6:18
British Virgin Islands
Gross Domestic Product by Academic Activity
at Factor Cost (US$ Million)
ECONOMIC
ACTIVITY
SECTOR |
1985 |
1989 |
| AGRICULTURE |
3.66 |
4.76 |
| MINING AND QUARRYING |
0.16 |
0.30 |
| MANUFACTURING |
2.31 |
4.30 |
| ELECTRICITY AND WATER |
2.87 |
5.21 |
| CONSTRUCTION |
5.91 |
9.45 |
| WHOLESALE AND RETAIL DISTRIBUTION |
6.61 |
11.20 |
| HOTELS AND RESTAURANTS |
18.0 |
28.25 |
| TRANSPORTATION AND COMMUNICATION |
8.70 |
21.28 |
| BANKS AND INSURANCE |
5.94 |
10.63 |
| REAL ESTATE AND HOUSING |
16.50 |
20.58 |
| GOVERNMENT SERVICES |
10.25 |
19.00 |
| OTHER SERVICES |
4.70 |
6.50 |
| LESS IMPUTED SERVICE CHARGE |
5.21 |
9.01 |
| GDP AT FACTOR COST |
80.40 |
132.45 |
| GROWTH RATE |
3.2 |
16.7 |
Source: BVI National report for ICPD, 1994
Table 6:19 shows the types of jobs, which were done by males and
females in 1981.
TABLE 6:19
EMPLOYMENT STATUS AND OCCUPATION BY GENDER IN 1981
| OCCUPATION |
FEMALE |
% FEMALE |
# MALE |
% MALE |
TOTAL |
PRO.TECH
WORKERS |
265 |
44.5 |
330 |
55.5 |
595 |
ADMIN. &
MANAGEMENT |
66 |
31.6 |
143 |
68.4 |
209 |
CLERICAL & REL.
WORKER |
395 |
78.1 |
|
22.0 |
506 |
| SALES WORKERS |
212 |
60.6 |
138 |
39.4 |
350 |
SERVICE
WORKER |
822 |
63.1 |
481 |
36.9 |
1303 |
AGRI. & REL.
WORKERS |
6 |
2.1 |
285 |
97.9 |
291 |
PROD. & REL.
WORKER |
79 |
4.8 |
1558 |
95.2 |
1637 |
| TOTAL |
1845 |
37.7 |
3046 |
62.3 |
4891 |
Source: 1980-91 Population Census, BVI
Table 6:19 shows a clear distinction between the jobs
done by women and men in 1981. While 68% of all administrative and
management workers were men, only 31% were women. However, 78% of those
who worked for those managers and administrators as clerical workers were
women while only 22% were men. About 60% and 63% of all sales and service
workers were also women, while only about 40% of, workers in those
categories were men. Only 85 of all female workers 1845 could be found in
agriculture and production related work while 1,843 of the 3,046 male
workers were employed in those fields.
The employment picture presented for 1981 corresponds
closely to that for the thirteen-year period preceding 1994, as obtained
from the Social Security Board in the BVI. (Women's Desk, 1994). Those
figures which represent 65% of all employees indicate that the
"majority of women whose professions are listed are
housekeepers/cleaners, maids, waitresses, dishwashers, cooks/kitchen
assistants". Many women were also secretaries, clerical workers,
sales clerks, teachers and nurses.
Table 6:20 below does an in-group analysis of occupations in 1981.
TABLE 6:20
PERCENTAGE EMPLOYMENT STATUS AND
OCCUPATION IN GENDER GROUP
| OCCUPATION |
# FEMALE |
% OF ALL
FEMALE |
# MALE |
% OF ALL
MALE |
| PRO.TECH |
265 |
14.4 |
330 |
10.8 |
ADMIN. &
MANAGEMENT |
66 |
3.6 |
143 |
4.7 |
| CLERICAL |
395 |
21.4 |
113 |
3.7 |
| SALES |
212 |
11.5 |
138 |
4.5 |
| SERVICE |
822 |
44.6 |
481 |
15.8 |
| AGRICULTURE |
6 |
0.33 |
285 |
9.4 |
| PRODUCTION |
79 |
4.3 |
1558 |
51.1 |
| TOTAL |
1845 |
100.0 |
3046 |
100.0 |
Source: 1980-81 Population Census, BVI
This table corroborates the 13 year findings of the
Social Security Board. The majority of women (77.5%) were service, sales
and clerical workers (44.6%, 11.5%, 21.4% respectively), while
professional and technical workers which would include teachers and nurses
accounted for another 14.4%. On the contrary, 51.1% of all men were
involved in production (which included construction) only 15.8% were in
service work, and 10.8% in professional and technical work. As we saw from
Table 6:5 only 43 of these men in professional/technical fields would have
been teachers, compared to 146 women.
Reports on the current situation of women in the work
force indicate that although women still remain in the minority in
management, the situation is improving. Today women are more often found
in the legal and accounting professions and are beginning to infiltrate
the fields traditionally occupied by males. Almost half of all heads of
departments, statutory boards and other agencies are women and two out of
five permanent secretaries are currently women. Women in the BVI are doing
better in the civil service than in the private sector.
Table 6:21 and 6:22 which follow, speak to employment
in industry between and within gender groups.
TABLE 6:21
INDUSTRIAL EMPLOYMENT BY GENDER 1981
| INDUSTRY |
FEMALE
# |
FEMALE
% |
MALE
# |
MALE
% |
TOTAL |
AGRICULTURE,
FOREST, HUNT |
6 |
2.2 |
272 |
97.8 |
278 |
MIN., REFIN,
QUARRY |
|
0.00 |
3 |
100.0 |
3 |
| MANUFACT. |
76 |
29.1 |
185 |
70.9 |
261 |
ELEC. GAS &
WATER |
12 |
1.9 |
619 |
98.1 |
631 |
CONSTRUCTION
& INSTALL |
3 |
5.0 |
57 |
95.0 |
60 |
| COMMERCE |
246 |
67.7 |
180 |
42.3 |
426 |
TRANS. STOR.
COMM. |
92 |
66.2 |
47 |
33.8 |
139 |
FINAN, INS,
REAL ESTATE |
65 |
22.3 |
226 |
77.7 |
291 |
| GOVERNMENT |
201 |
33.6 |
397 |
66.4 |
598 |
COMMUNITY
SERVICES |
173 |
62..2 |
105 |
37.8 |
278 |
OTHER
SERVICES |
961 |
60.9 |
927 |
49.1 |
1888 |
| TOTAL |
1835 |
37.8 |
3018 |
62.2 |
4853 |
Source: 1980-81 Population Census BVI National Report
for ICPD 1994
Worthy of note here is the finding that in 1981 the
areas of Commerce which include hotels, restaurants and wholesale and
retail businesses and account for 28.25 and 1 1.20 of the ~GDP, are over
represented by women who outnumber men by 67.7% to 42.3% (Table 6:18).
However, we also note from Table 6:19 that 60% of all sales workers and
63% of all service workers are women. So although women outnumber the men
in these areas, they are in the subordinate positions where they earn less
money.
The same type of pattern is consistent throughout these
tables for in areas like Finance, Real Estate, Government Services and
Transportation and Communication where we find that the GDP is high, even
if the majority of workers seem to be women we must interpret women's
financial benefit by realizing that 68% of all administrators and 55% of
all professional/technical persons who would be earning the highest
salaries are men.
TABLE 6:22
PERCENTAGE INDUSTRIAL EMPLOYMENT IN GENDER GROUP
|
INDUSTRY |
#
FEMALE |
FEMALE
% OF ALL
FEMALES |
#
MALE |
MALE
% OF ALL
MALES |
AGRICULTURE,
FOREST, HUNT |
6 |
0.3 |
272 |
9.03 |
MIN., REFIN,
QUARRY |
- |
|
3 |
0.1 |
| MANUFACTORY |
76 |
|
185 |
6.1 |
ELEC. GAS &
WATER |
12 |
0.6 |
619 |
20.5 |
CONSTRUCTION
& INSTALL |
3 |
0.2 |
57 |
1.9 |
| COMMERCE |
246 |
13.4 |
180 |
6.0 |
TRANS. STOR.
COMM. |
92 |
6.0 |
47 |
1.6 |
FINAN, INS,
REAL ESTATE |
65 |
3.5 |
226 |
7.9 |
| GOVERNMENT |
201 |
11.0 |
397 |
13.2 |
COMMUNITY
SERVICES |
173 |
9.4 |
105 |
3.5 |
OTHER
SERVICES |
961 |
52.4 |
927 |
30.7 |
| TOTAL |
1835 |
100.0 |
3018 |
100.0 |
Source: 1980-81 Population Census BVI
Table 6:22 does not provide additional information
except to demonstrate that in 1981 over 60 per cent of all women compared
to 33 per cent of all men were employed in areas that contributed very
little to the GDP - that is, the areas of community and other services.
This corroborates the finding that women were employed, by and large, in
lower paying jobs.
TABLE 6:23
PERSONS EMPLOYED BY OCCUPATION AND GENDER, 1991
|
Occupation |
Female
Nos |
Female
% |
Male
Nos |
Male
% |
Total |
| Professional & Technical Workers |
693 |
47.1 |
779 |
52.9 |
1,472 |
| Administrators and other Managers |
335 |
40.8 |
487 |
59.2 |
822 |
| Clerical and Related Workers |
815 |
81.2 |
189 |
18.8 |
1,005 |
| Service and Sales Workers |
1,782 |
62.4 |
1,075 |
37.6 |
2,857 |
| Agriculture and Related Workers |
8 |
2.9 |
269 |
97.1 |
277 |
| Production and Related Workers |
125 |
5.6 |
2,091 |
94.4 |
2,216 |
| Not Stated |
22 |
43.1 |
29 |
56.9 |
51 |
| Total |
3,781 |
43.5 |
4,919 |
56.5 |
8,700 |
A comparison of employment by occupation and gender
between the period 1971 to 1991 shows that females have increased their
share in all occupational groups in 1991, with the highest increase
occuring in the occupational group Administrators and other managers, at
the same time the proportion of males in all occupational groups have
declined over the ten year period. Females continue to dominate the
occupational groups clerical and related workers and sales and service
workers accounting for 81.2% and 64.2 respectively of those groups.
Traditionally. female workers show little preference for employment as
Agricultural production workers and the trend has continued in 1991.
The status of women in the labour market has improved
since 1980 in management professional and technical occupations.
TABLE 6:24
ECONOMICALLY ACTIVE POPULATION BY
OCCUPATIONAL GROUP AND SEX, 1991
| Occupation |
Female
Nos |
Female
% |
Male
Nos |
Male
% |
Total |
| Professional & Technical Workers |
693 |
18.3 |
779 |
15.8 |
1,472 |
| Administrators and other Managers |
335 |
8.9 |
487 |
9.9 |
822 |
| Clerical and Related Workers |
816 |
21.6 |
189 |
3.8 |
1,005 |
| Service and Sales Workers |
1,782 |
47.1 |
1,075 |
21.9 |
2,857 |
| Agriculture and Related Workers |
8 |
0.2 |
269 |
5.5 |
277 |
| Production and Related Workers |
125 |
3.3 |
2,091 |
42.5 |
2,216 |
| Not Stated |
22 |
0.6 |
29 |
0.6 |
51 |
| Total |
3,781 |
100.0 |
4,919 |
100.0 |
8,700 |
Over the period 1980 to 1991 female workers employed as
clerks, sales and service workers declined from 77.5 percent in 1980 to
68.7 percent in 1991. Of that broad group, female workers employed as
Service and Sales workers declined from 56.1 percent in 1980 to 47.1
percent in 1991 while those employed as clerks moved up marginally from
21.4 percent in 1980 to 21.6 percent in 1991. Male workers employed ire
the group, production and related workers accounted for 42.5 percent of
the total male labour force, compared with 51.1 percent in 1980. The
category of workers in the occupational group production and related
workers include craft and related trade workers, plant and machine
operation and construction workers. Both male and females recorded
declined in the number engaged in agriculture.
Figure 1:

As Table 6:23 shows, in 1991, women continue to make
less money than men. In fact, according to figures from the Development
Planning Unit men from the western region (Table 6:24) which include the
United States and Europe are making on average, mote than two times per
month what BVI women are making more than three times what 'Immigrant
women from the other Caribbean islands are making per month.
The low income figure for women point to women's
continued subordinate status in society. In particular Caribbean women are
primarily to be found in low income occupations where many may be making
less than the minimum wage. As has been pointed out before, women's low
wages make them vulnerable to poverty and marginalization and this has
obvious adverse effects on them and their families.
Figure 2:

Figure 3

Table 6:25
Women by Graduation Status and Occupation, 1991
|
Occupation |
Graduation Status |
| Graduated |
Ungraduated |
| Frequency |
Percent |
Frequency |
Percent |
| Legislators and Managers |
279 |
11.4 |
86 |
3.3 |
| Professionals |
297 |
12.2 |
15 |
0.6 |
| Asst Professionals |
427 |
17.5 |
54 |
2.1 |
| Clerks |
661 |
27.1 |
192 |
7.4 |
| Sales and Services |
408 |
16.7 |
810 |
31.3 |
| Gardeners |
2 |
0.1 |
16 |
0.6 |
| Craft and Related |
42 |
1.7 |
102 |
3.9 |
| Industry |
7 |
0.3 |
13 |
0.5 |
| Elementary |
155 |
6.3 |
767 |
29.7 |
| Not Applicable |
163 |
6.7 |
530 |
20.5 |
| Total |
2,441 |
100.0 |
2,585 |
100.0 |
Over 41.0% of graduated female were employed in jobs requiring high
skills. A mere 6.3% were doing elementary jobs. Of undergraduate females,
only 6.0% were in high skill jobs while 29.7% did elementary work.
Table 6:27
Women by Graduation Status and Industry, 1991
|
Industry |
Graduation
Status |
| Graduated |
Ungraduated |
| Frequency |
Percent |
Frequency |
Percent |
| Agriculture |
5 |
0.2 |
1 |
0.6 |
| Fishing |
- |
- |
1 |
0.0 |
| Mining |
3 |
0.1 |
1 |
.0 |
| Manufacturing |
83 |
3.4 |
107 |
4.1 |
| Electricity Gas Water |
16 |
0.7 |
6 |
0.2 |
| Construction |
25 |
1.0 |
9 |
0.3 |
| Wholesale Retail |
320 |
13.1 |
327 |
12.6 |
| Hotel Restaurant |
421 |
17.2 |
793 |
30.7 |
| Transport Communication |
138 |
5.7 |
45 |
1.7 |
| Financial |
210 |
8.6 |
26 |
1.0 |
| Real Estate |
207 |
8.5 |
62 |
2.4 |
| Public Administration |
242 |
9.9 |
60 |
2.3 |
| Education |
254 |
10.4 |
43 |
1.7 |
| Health Social Welfare |
166 |
6.8 |
87 |
3.4 |
| Other Social |
99 |
4.1 |
72 |
2.8 |
| Private Households |
84 |
3.4 |
379 |
14.7 |
| Not Applicable |
168 |
6.9 |
552 |
21.4 |
| Total |
2441 |
100.0 |
2585 |
100.0 |
Just over 3% of graduated women worked in Private Households and this
compares to the 14.7% of the undergraduate. Just over 17% of graduated
women worked in Hotels and Restaurants while 31.7% of undergraduate women
were employed in this type of occupation.
Table 6:28
Women by Graduation Status and Type of Employment, 1991
|
Type of Employment |
Graduation
Status |
| Graduated |
Ungraduated |
| Frequency |
Percent |
Frequency |
Percent |
| Not Applicable |
445 |
18.2 |
916 |
35.4 |
| Government |
540 |
22.1 |
163 |
6.3 |
| Private |
1290 |
52.8 |
1371 |
53.0 |
| Unpaid Worker |
8 |
.3 |
7 |
.3 |
| Employer |
91 |
3.7 |
51 |
2.0 |
| Own Account |
63 |
2.6 |
59 |
2.3 |
| Not Stated |
4 |
.2 |
18 |
.7 |
| Total |
2,441 |
100.0 |
2,585 |
100.0 |
The concentration of graduated and undergraduate women
was very high in the private sector (about 53.0%) in both instances.
However, while 22.1% of graduated women worked in the Public Service, only
6.3% of the undergraduate women in this sector. Over 35% of the
undergraduate were formally unemployed and this compares to 18.2% of
graduated women.
The mean monthly income for graduated women was USD
923.08 which is more than double the USD 425.53 earned by undergraduate
women. The median monthly incomes were USD 750.00 and USD 310.00 for
graduated and undergraduate women respectively.
The unemployment rate for 1991 among graduated women
stood at 2.25% while for undergraduate women this measure was 4.77%. For
the previous year (1990) these statistics were 2.07% and 3.98% for
graduated and undergraduate women respectively.
Almost 56% of graduated women and their first pregnancy
at or before age 19 years. For these same ages, over 68% of undergraduate
women had their first pregnancy. Of graduated women, 79.6% had 2 of less
live births while for undergraduate women this statistic was 55.3%.
Therefore, only 21.4% of graduated women had 3 or more livebirths while
44.7% of graduated women had 3 or more livebirths.
WORK PERMITS
Because of the high percentage of immigrant workers in
the BVI it is necessary to highlight some of the issues which affect them
directly. Fifty per cent of the workforce hold work permits, which are
issued to non BVIslanders either because locals are not qualified or do
not want the jobs under question.
Domestic workers, who are at the low end of the
employment spectrum and who are traditionally non-BVIslanders, are the
targets of much reported exploitation with regards to the length of their
working day, the failure of employers to pay into the social security
scheme although deductions have been made from worker's pay, and sexual
harassment.
BVI men reportedly also take sexual advantage of
"down-island" women as they know that these women often will not
report them for fear of losing their jobs. Cases of sexual harassment are
treated as labour disputes because of the inadequacy of the BVI laws to
provide for appropriate legal action. This is of course, unsatisfactory
for the non-BVI women. (See also Sections 3 and 4 for further discussions
regarding immigrant women).
PROGRAMMES AND ACTIVITIES
The Women's Desk in the BVI has been working behind the
scenes with the labour Department to develop an association of low income
workers. The Desk has been instrumental in reporting and publicizing
labour problems and this has helped to create an information bank as
people call in to report their individual situations.
The low income status of women in relation to the cost
of living in the BV~I has been the precipitant of many social problems. It
has meant that women have bad to work at two and sometimes three jobs in
order to pay her bills and support her family. Many of these women are
"semi-literate, many are not indigenous BVIslanders. For all these
reasons and more, employers often take advantage of them "(Women's
Desk, 1994 p. 4).
The Women's Desk posits the view that if an association
of low income workers were to be formed it would allow workers to address
issues like child care, sexual harassment and immigration problems as a
group. "Government departments such as Health and labour would be
able to design specific campaigns targeted at this segment of the
population and be assured of an audience. Programmes and workshops aimed
at improving professionalism, perfecting literary skills, imparting
parenting knowledge and so on could more easily be done within the context
of an existing association...... (Women's Desk, 1994:4).
To Next Section>
|